Do you think ASOIAF (aka Game of Thrones) is worse than AOT in terms of writing? If yes, why?

[Ramsay_Truecelton]

I've watched both, and to me they're pretty much equal, even considering the last shitty seasons of GOT. However, a lot of tiktokcels are sure that AOT is far above, which doesn't make much sense to me.

 

[nouc]

I've watched both, and to me they're pretty much equal, even considering the last shitty seasons of GOT. However, a lot of tiktokcels are sure that AOT is far above, which doesn't make much sense to me.

Paid agents

 

[Ramsay_Truecelton]

Paid agents

Agree

 

[tulasdanslos]

I thought @Subhuman Niceguy made this thread before but not really.

It would have been a funny reference ngl.

 

[Pikacel]

AOTroons worst fanbase ever

 

[Rapemaxxer]

No. ASOIAF is peak fiction.

 

[thenewdawnfades]

read the books they're way better than the show

 

[WYRM]

Even the worst seasons of GOT are better than season 4 of AOT

 

[slavcel11]

Haven't watched or read AOT but there's no way in hell it beats ASOIAF in the books (not that ASOIAF is flawless mind you). If we're talking the television series it's whatever.

 

[incel3roar]

AOTroons worst fanbase ever

For real, absolutely full of fucking normfags

 

[kevkon]

I've watched both, and to me they're pretty much equal, even considering the last shitty seasons of GOT. However, a lot of tiktokcels are sure that AOT is far above, which doesn't make much sense to me.

They are both EXTREMELY similar in writing quality to me. Almost neck and neck I wouldn’t be able to choose which I prefer. I’ve often called attack on titan “the game of thrones of anime” and I think it fits quite accurately no?

 

[kevkon]

AOTroons worst fanbase ever

The only good aot fans are the Eren defenders. Everyone else is a self hating cuck.

 

[kevkon]

Even the worst seasons of GOT are better than season 4 of AOT

You mean when the story started to get good? Lol let me guess, you can’t watch anything if there’s not an explosion or fight scene every 5 seconds? Sounds like an action-tard take.

Edit: my bad this sounded too hostile

 

[WYRM]

You mean when the story started to get good? Lol let me guess, you can’t watch anything if there’s not an explosion or fight scene every 5 seconds? Sounds like an action-tard take.

Edit: my bad this sounded too hostile

Nah I disliked it because everyone acted completely out of character and made retarded decisions especially at the end

 

[Ramsay_Truecelton]

read the books they're way better than the show

I am working on that (currently reading Clash of the kings)

 

[Ramsay_Truecelton]

Even the worst seasons of GOT are better than season 4 of AOT

4 season of AOT cant be as bad as season 8, lol

 

[Ramsay_Truecelton]

They are both EXTREMELY similar in writing quality to me. Almost neck and neck I wouldn’t be able to choose which I prefer. I’ve often called attack on titan “the game of thrones of anime” and I think it fits quite accurately no?

I think they are "equal" only in storytelling and thats because of fucking disgusting final seasons seasons of GOT, however GOT universe has far better worldbuliding and lore, which are significant flaws of AOT

 

[Pikacel]

I think they are "equal" only in storytelling and thats because of fucking disgusting final seasons seasons of GOT, however GOT universe has far better worldbuliding and lore, which are significant flaws of AOT

The story in 1-4 is too good, so many good scenes too

Better than the worldbuilding even