I think it's perfectly relevant to call out the fact that you're a Jew when you post in a thread defending Jews.
That's called a genetic fallacy.
Normies and women especially lack agency; they need it to be beaten into them.
If someone lacks agency, you can't morally hold them accountable. You can’t punish a puppet for what its puppeteer does. Also, what differentiates normie Jews and women, normies and women of other races, and what differentiates Jewish elite and the elite of other ethnicities (regardless of disproportionality)?
Jews control the media, Hollywood, banking, and government. All the mechanisms that influence normies. They print the newspapers, they make the movies, they decide who gets loans, and they make the laws. This means total control over normies and women.
There is a disproportionate Jewish presence in elite institutions, particularly Ashkenazi Jews (as I have said IIRC). But this does not logically equate to
all Jews controlling everything. Just as not all white people were slave owners or colonizers, not all Jews are media moguls or bankers. Guilt by association is not valid reasoning.
Just because normies and women are retards doesn't mean that's acceptable. They require a firm hand to start acting right; left to their own devices, they create devastation.
I agree that the vast majority people (irrespective of ethnicity) need to be guided to
some extent, but you cannot deny agency entirely and then assign moral responsibility.
I don't see how saying Jews have immense control over cultivating outcomes and saying that normies and women should be held accountable contradict each other.
It contradicts if you're claiming
absolute control by Jews. If all behavior is externally manipulated, then accountability is largely a meaningless term. This also opens up massive philosophical quandaries and implications.
Women don't have their own agency; they require outside influence to be held accountable.
Someone with no agency can't logically be held accountable for their actions; I also find the notion that women have zero agency nonsensical, for it ignores decades of intentional subversion committed by females, as well as various harmfully influential works produced by a minority of them. Women are a force to be reckoned with, especially when it comes to the soft power they hold in society, and the manipulative and deceitful behavior they are often capable of exhibiting—and, of course, one should not forget the in-group bias they possess, which allows them to effectively control society and dictate who is 'in' vs. 'out'. Do they have decreased mental faculties in other areas, such as consciousness, sentience, philosophy, science, and ethics? Sure. But saying they have no agency at all is a massive leap.
"Monolithic global puppeteer." No clue what you're saying, I never alluded to that.
You literally described a group that "writes the script". That is, by definition, a monolithic global puppeteer. If you don't see the allusion, you're not thinking about what your words actually imply.
"It's a tiny elite of Jews, not all Jews". Then will you concede that it was a small minority of white people in the past who are responsible for slavery and colonialism, and that to blame white people as a whole is wrong?
Yes. That’s exactly my point. Collective blame based on a minority is wrong regardless of the group, whether it’s Jews, whites, blacks, or anyone else.
It's not just about what you think, though; society says that all whites are culpable for the actions of some whites in the past. Until that narrative changes, I will continue to apply that logic to all Jews.
So because you disagree with how white people are treated by society, you’ll mirror the same flawed logic onto Jews? You know what they say, an eye for an eye and the world goes blind (in some cases).
It's also important to note that, unlike slavery or colonialism, Jewish power is something that exists in the here and now.
There's a difference between blaming the elite who push for degeneracy and exploitation as a class (who are not all Jewish, obviously; in fact, they remain a minority in most positions of power, hence the keyword disproportionate) and collective blame. Also, the fact that something exists now doesn’t make collective guilt rational.
I will continue to blame Jews collectively, as that's what society deemed most appropriate when it comes to judging groups.
That’s your prerogative, but it’s not a logical stance. You’re doing the exact thing you accuse leftist ideologues of doing: holding entire groups responsible for the actions of a few.