Based Bianca Devins: Federal judge throws out lawsuit involving sex tape of murdered 17-year-old e-girl

[Incline]

View: https://www.reddit.com/r/IncelTear/comments/ofsgxp/holy_shit/

This is Bianca Devins. If you've been around here for a while, you've almost certainly heard of her.

The 17-year-old daughter of a single mom was violently murdered by Brandon Andrew Clark in Utica, New York over three years ago. Clark was not an incel, despite many claims to the contrary. That is a piece of disinformation that survives to this very day.

In reality, Clark was a 21-year-old bluepilled, normie simp whom Devins had initially met on Discord. As he was 21, he was able to buy alcohol for Devins and her high school friends. Clark seemed to have been infatuated with Devins almost immediately, adding two tattoos dedicated to her; but his romantic feelings weren't mutual.

So six weeks after they met, Clark planned to murder Devins and commit suicide afterwards. On July 14th, 2019, after a Nicole Dollanganger concert, Clark raped Devins in his car whilst videotaping the encounter with a dashboard camera. He then slowly murdered her with his knife as she pleaded for her life. After Devins died, Clark sent a picture of her body to her Discord server. The image went viral.

Spoiler: Image of Devins with her throat slashed

View attachment 667699

Clark failed to commit suicide and is now serving a life sentence at Attica Correctional Facility. He will be eligible for parole in 2044, after serving 25 years.

The Lawsuit

View attachment 667703

The prosecution of Brandon Clark (pictured here) was handled by the Utica Police Department and the Oneida County District Attorney's Office. Given the enormous public interest in the case, multiple media organizations filed FOIL requests to obtain related documents.

For one reason or another, perhaps poor records management, Oneida County prosecutors allegedly sent producers at CBS' 48 Hours and A&E a copy of the sex and murder tape recorded by Clark. This was likely improper, as Bianca Devins was 17 at the time of her death. Additionally, one Utica PD officer is alleged to have shown part of a body camera video to members of the public at a local bar; in that video, officers wrestle Clark to the ground whilst Devins' mutilated corpse is visible in the background.

No, you didn't misread this. The cops and the government, of all people, allegedly distributed child pornography and snuff film featuring Devins to the media.

When Devins' mother learned of this, she was extremely distraught. So in July 2021, roughly two years after the murder, she sued Oneida County on behalf of Bianca's estate in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of New York. Devins' estate was represented by Carrie Goldberg, a feminist lawyer in New York City. If you didn't know, Goldberg is the same ambulance chaser who once wrote a letter to the U.S. Department of Justice asking for the prosecution of our forum's founders, Serge and Master.

You can read the 22-page complaint here:

Spoiler: Estate of Bianca Devins v. Oneida County (Complaint Dkt No. 1)

View: https://imgur.com/a/vWJduUZ

The Decision

View attachment 667711

The Oneida County DA's Office, under the leadership of District Attorney Scott McNamara (pictured here), argued that even if the allegations were true, the claims should be dismissed for a variety of reasons. And on September 29th, 2022, U.S. District Judge Glenn T. Suddaby sided with the County on dismissal. You can read the order here:

Spoiler: Estate of Bianca Devins v. Oneida County (Order Dkt No. 44)

View: https://imgur.com/a/Lzb8avH

View attachment 667716
Judge Glenn T. Suddaby

The 45-page order contains numerous points of law which will bore you so I won't elaborate too much, but the most significant one is Judge Suddaby's treatment of the federal child pornography claims under 18 U.S.C. §§2252A and 2255.

Here, the Court reasoned that although the material within the sex and murder tape constituted child pornography, Bianca Devins' estate lacked standing because she suffered no reputational harm—as a result of being dead at the time the child pornography was allegedly distributed. Therefore, Judge Suddaby granted the Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(1) and (6) motion to dismiss.

Or in other words, he BTFO'd the dead roastie's lawsuit.

View attachment 667719
Excerpt of Order, p. 37

Needless to say, child pornography is not great. But I do have to applaud Judge Suddaby for having the courage and conviction to apply the letter of the law, no matter what the personal feelings of Devins' simps may be on the issue. Absolutely BASED decision!

View attachment 667681

Spoiler: Tagging potentially interested individuals

@Master @MiSKiRaT @CurryLMAO @Noseman @Ricordanza @Izayacel @Ehwhatever @wastedTime @Pancakecel @zionpill @kretschmer @NorthernWind @My Name Jeff @RuudVanNistelrooy @Rice Rice Baby

He is a mogger

he just has shitty hair if he did hair surgery or other hair treatments she would fuck him

 

[ChrolloLucilfer04]

she was a dumb e-whore lol

we made fun of her when her photos got leaked. her death was cause of a single slut household

 

[Uncle Death]

dumb whore got what she deserve, though she would get away with it because shes a woman?

Based judge honestly.

 

[Verxis]

I don't understand the outrage. It's nothing to lose your head over.

 

[fukurou]

why do teen sluts so often wear cheap bracelets?

 

[PPEcel]

dumb whore got what she deserve, though she would get away with it because shes a woman?

Based judge honestly.

Yup, based judge.

why do teen sluts so often wear cheap bracelets?

Because they're teens.

 

[novarem]

imagine killing yourself or going to jail over some foid jfl.

At least he took her down in the process. That, I can respect.

also

There is the video of rape?

Lmao if it ever got leaked, roasties would be the first ones drooling all over the footage seeing as how they fetishize killers like dahmer, bundy and the like.

 

[PPEcel]

Lmao if it ever got leaked, roasties would be the first ones drooling all over the footage seeing as how they fetishize killers like dahmer, bundy and the like.

no shit

 

[TiredofTalking]

Ngl guy is spooky as fuck.

 

[Hapacalyptist]

There is the video of rape?

Asking the important questions

 

[Glerforpus]

She’s a whore and deserved it. Normies are coping

 

[67InchesSubhuman]

imagine killing yourself or going to jail over some foid jfl.

at least he did something. most incels will end up killing themselves in a dark, empty room by age 40, which will only please normies. so if you are completely hopeless and are going to commit suicide, get revenge first. incels are already socially perceived as bad as nazis, we have no reputation preserve.

if you are religious you are going to hell after you die if you are not you will just cease to exist. there is nothing stopping you besides being a low test faggot. make them pay.

 

[ChadFUXXbetaBUXX]

at least he did something. most incels will end up killing themselves in a dark, empty room by age 40, which will only please normies. so if you are completely hopeless and are going to commit suicide, get revenge first. incels are already socially perceived as bad as nazis, we have no reputation preserve.

if you are religious you are going to hell after you die if you are not you will just cease to exist. there is nothing stopping you besides being a low test faggot. make them pay.

true

 

[AsiaCel]

He is a mogger

he just has shitty hair if he did hair surgery or other hair treatments she would fuck him

Based

 

[AsiaCel]

at least he did something. most incels will end up killing themselves in a dark, empty room by age 40, which will only please normies. so if you are completely hopeless and are going to commit suicide, get revenge first. incels are already socially perceived as bad as nazis, we have no reputation preserve.

if you are religious you are going to hell after you die if you are not you will just cease to exist. there is nothing stopping you besides being a low test faggot. make them pay.

I don't think hell is guaranteed as long you're fighting for a just cause

 

[PPEcel]

I don't think hell is guaranteed as long you're fighting for a just cause

it doesn't exist

 

[Mworld]

Based judge tbh.

 

[Doctor Manhattan]

Definitely not an incel because bianca herself recognized that they both had sex before. This case is another example of non-incel violence, perpetrated by a guy who gets laid

View attachment 667723

 

[The Enforcer]

clown world amirite

 

[PPEcel]

ikr

 

[UnluckyCell]

The bianca case is lifefuel, teasing giga ewhore got what she deserved

 

[RREEEEEEEEE]

>17
>child pornography

Pick one.

 

[PPEcel]

>17
>child pornography

Pick one.

Based on U.S. federal law: under 18 = child pornography.

 

[RREEEEEEEEE]

Based on U.S. federal law: under 18 = child pornography.

Nothing based about this.

 

[Lux]

Fortunate decision. Should not even be considered child related. Even in places were the AoC is reasonable this law remains.

 

[I.N.C.E.L.S. Boss]

Definitely not an incel because bianca herself recognized that they both had sex before. This case is another example of non-incel violence, perpetrated by a guy who gets laid

View attachment 667723

Basically, they had sex and she told him you are just another guy while he thought by sexing her, he was her bf.
Got mad & killed her.

@PPEcel why is this interesting?

 

[based_meme]

Carrie Goldberg, a feminist lawyer in New York Holy kike overload jfl

 

[The Enforcer]

Basically, they had sex and she told him you are just another guy while he thought by sexing her, he was her bf.
Got mad & killed her.

@PPEcel why is this interesting?

Pretty much. Typical sex haver normie rage. Non-incels are terrorists

 

[PointOfNoReturn]

I don't understand the outrage. It's nothing to lose your head over.

 

[universallyabhorred]

It's funny how they feel the need to blame us for literally anything bad that could happen to anybody...

I guess we're the new boogeyman now; the definition of "incel" can simply change according to bluepillers and the media depending on what exact agenda they want to push when calling someone that.

Isn't he an LTN? And if he never had sex with a woman or a girlfriend or any sexual contact without paying, wouldn't he be technically incel, even though he was bluepilled and never associated with us?

 

[PPEcel]

Isn't he an LTN? And if he never had sex with a woman or a girlfriend or any sexual contact without paying, wouldn't he be technically incel, even though he was bluepilled and never associated with us?

This is one of those very few grey areas vis-a-vis the LTN/incel distinction. Devins was "friends" with Clark because Clark was 21 and could therefore buy alcohol for Devins and her friends.

 

[Copexodius Maximus]

View: https://www.reddit.com/r/IncelTear/comments/ofsgxp/holy_shit/

This is Bianca Devins. If you've been around here for a while, you've almost certainly heard of her.

The 17-year-old daughter of a single mom was violently murdered by Brandon Andrew Clark in Utica, New York over three years ago. Clark was not an incel, despite many claims to the contrary. That is a piece of disinformation that survives to this very day.

In reality, Clark was a 21-year-old bluepilled, normie simp whom Devins had initially met on Discord. As he was 21, he was able to buy alcohol for Devins and her high school friends. Clark seemed to have been infatuated with Devins almost immediately, adding two tattoos dedicated to her; but his romantic feelings weren't mutual.

So six weeks after they met, Clark planned to murder Devins and commit suicide afterwards. On July 14th, 2019, after a Nicole Dollanganger concert, Clark raped Devins in his car whilst videotaping the encounter with a dashboard camera. He then slowly murdered her with his knife as she pleaded for her life. After Devins died, Clark sent a picture of her body to her Discord server. The image went viral.

Spoiler: Image of Devins with her throat slashed

View attachment 667699

Clark failed to commit suicide and is now serving a life sentence at Attica Correctional Facility. He will be eligible for parole in 2044, after serving 25 years.

The Lawsuit

View attachment 667703

The prosecution of Brandon Clark (pictured here) was handled by the Utica Police Department and the Oneida County District Attorney's Office. Given the enormous public interest in the case, multiple media organizations filed FOIL requests to obtain related documents.

For one reason or another, perhaps poor records management, Oneida County prosecutors allegedly sent producers at CBS' 48 Hours and A&E a copy of the sex and murder tape recorded by Clark. This was likely improper, as Bianca Devins was 17 at the time of her death. Additionally, one Utica PD officer is alleged to have shown part of a body camera video to members of the public at a local bar; in that video, officers wrestle Clark to the ground whilst Devins' mutilated corpse is visible in the background.

No, you didn't misread this. The cops and the government, of all people, allegedly distributed child pornography and snuff film featuring Devins to the media.

When Devins' mother learned of this, she was extremely distraught. So in July 2021, roughly two years after the murder, she sued Oneida County on behalf of Bianca's estate in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of New York. Devins' estate was represented by Carrie Goldberg, a feminist lawyer in New York City. If you didn't know, Goldberg is the same ambulance chaser who once wrote a letter to the U.S. Department of Justice asking for the prosecution of our forum's founders, Serge and Master.

You can read the 22-page complaint here:

Spoiler: Estate of Bianca Devins v. Oneida County (Complaint Dkt No. 1)

View: https://imgur.com/a/vWJduUZ

The Decision

View attachment 667711

The Oneida County DA's Office, under the leadership of District Attorney Scott McNamara (pictured here), argued that even if the allegations were true, the claims should be dismissed for a variety of reasons. And on September 29th, 2022, U.S. District Judge Glenn T. Suddaby sided with the County on dismissal. You can read the order here:

Spoiler: Estate of Bianca Devins v. Oneida County (Order Dkt No. 44)

View: https://imgur.com/a/Lzb8avH

View attachment 667716
Judge Glenn T. Suddaby

The 45-page order contains numerous points of law which will bore you so I won't elaborate too much, but the most significant one is Judge Suddaby's treatment of the federal child pornography claims under 18 U.S.C. §§2252A and 2255.

Here, the Court reasoned that although the material within the sex and murder tape constituted child pornography, Bianca Devins' estate lacked standing because she suffered no reputational harm—as a result of being dead at the time the child pornography was allegedly distributed. Therefore, Judge Suddaby granted the Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(1) and (6) motion to dismiss.

Or in other words, he BTFO'd the dead roastie's lawsuit.

View attachment 667719
Excerpt of Order, p. 37

Needless to say, child pornography is not great. But I do have to applaud Judge Suddaby for having the courage and conviction to apply the letter of the law, no matter what the personal feelings of Devins' simps may be on the issue. Absolutely BASED decision!

View attachment 667681

Spoiler: Tagging potentially interested individuals

@Master @MiSKiRaT @CurryLMAO @Noseman @Ricordanza @Izayacel @Ehwhatever @wastedTime @Pancakecel @zionpill @kretschmer @NorthernWind @My Name Jeff @RuudVanNistelrooy @Rice Rice Baby

Holy shit that was an amazing story. Firstly, that picture of the girl’s neck sliced is disturbing. Second, why is sharing child pornography only banned if it will cause reputation harm? Whores don’t have any reputation these days, so revealing the reality of a foid being a whore shouldn’t be damaging anything.

And lastly, fuck that whore lawyer bitch cunt. I wish it was her who was raped and had her neck slit (in video game) instead of the teenage chick.

 

[PPEcel]

Holy shit that was an amazing story. Firstly, that picture of the girl’s neck sliced is disturbing. Second, why is sharing child pornography only banned if it will cause reputation harm? Whores don’t have any reputation these days, so revealing the reality of a foid being a whore shouldn’t be damaging anything.

And lastly, fuck that whore lawyer bitch cunt. I wish it was her who was raped and had her neck slit (in video game) instead of the teenage chick.

Child pornography is criminal no matter how alive the purported child victim is. However, whether the purported child victim has the capacity to sue in civil court is a different story, and here this decision hinged on a question of federal civil procedure.

 

[Copexodius Maximus]

Child pornography is criminal no matter how alive the purported child victim is. However, whether the purported child victim has the capacity to sue in civil court is a different story, and here this decision hinged on a question of federal civil procedure.

Is it legal to have the underage pornography if they killed the person? Or are all the people with the video in the clear? Also, if the woman survived her family would be able to sue the guy for sharing her porn on top of him going to prison for rape? How would they even get the money if he’s broke and in prison?

 

[MierableAndIncel]

Well done. Whore got what she deserved.

Guy should be let free and given several million dollars for the punishment his baldcel Norwooding ass is going to be dealt by soyciety. Give him guns and knives. Let him dig up the whore's corpse and rape it repeatedly again.

This guy needs to be given some fentanyl, several pipe bombs, and I windowless white van all for self-defense and personal safety.

should also give him a rope so he can jump in it

 

[Govid_Dorious]

It's funny how they feel the need to blame us for literally anything bad that could happen to anybody...

I guess we're the new boogeyman now; the definition of "incel" can simply change according to bluepillers and the media depending on what exact agenda they want to push when calling someone that.

 

[Puppeter]

The foid was cute imo

 

[mlcurrycel]

I'm happy Bianca died but I'm not happy that the unprofessional behaviour of cops was excused.

I'm happy the feminist lawyer was BTFO'd.

 

[Kentuckycel]

She deserved it kek.

 

[Repulsive123]

nothing of value lost

 

[Mrugly420]

Smoke that Bianca pack

 

[calimero]

You should have studied law, easy good grades for you

 

[BornToLose]

The foid was a cunt imo

 

[Slut_Annihilator298]

E Thots take advantage of crazy mentally ill simps all the time, I don't know why people got so shocked over it.

She paid the price for being a fucking cunt whore. She burns in hell now.

 

[Logic55]

Can you show me the evidence of the feminist lawyer sending a letter to the DOJ requesting the prosecution of Master and Serge?

 

[suicidecase]

He was intent on getting head off her one way or the other.

 

[bus27jihad]

Wonder if the tape will ever "leak"?

Its techinclly cp so the chances of the tape leaking are low

Btw IT wont touch this

 

[Fat Link]

He was intent on getting head off her one way or the other.

 

[thisissparta420]

View: https://www.reddit.com/r/IncelTear/comments/ofsgxp/holy_shit/

This is Bianca Devins. If you've been around here for a while, you've almost certainly heard of her.

The 17-year-old daughter of a single mom was violently murdered by Brandon Andrew Clark in Utica, New York over three years ago. Clark was not an incel, despite many claims to the contrary. That is a piece of disinformation that survives to this very day.

In reality, Clark was a 21-year-old bluepilled, normie simp whom Devins had initially met on Discord. As he was 21, he was able to buy alcohol for Devins and her high school friends. Clark seemed to have been infatuated with Devins almost immediately, adding two tattoos dedicated to her; but his romantic feelings weren't mutual.

So six weeks after they met, Clark planned to murder Devins and commit suicide afterwards. On July 14th, 2019, after a Nicole Dollanganger concert, Clark raped Devins in his car whilst videotaping the encounter with a dashboard camera. He then slowly murdered her with his knife as she pleaded for her life. After Devins died, Clark sent a picture of her body to her Discord server. The image went viral.

Spoiler: Image of Devins with her throat slashed

View attachment 667699

Clark failed to commit suicide and is now serving a life sentence at Attica Correctional Facility. He will be eligible for parole in 2044, after serving 25 years.

The Lawsuit

View attachment 667703

The prosecution of Brandon Clark (pictured here) was handled by the Utica Police Department and the Oneida County District Attorney's Office. Given the enormous public interest in the case, multiple media organizations filed FOIL requests to obtain related documents.

For one reason or another, perhaps poor records management, Oneida County prosecutors allegedly sent producers at CBS' 48 Hours and A&E a copy of the sex and murder tape recorded by Clark. This was likely improper, as Bianca Devins was 17 at the time of her death. Additionally, one Utica PD officer is alleged to have shown part of a body camera video to members of the public at a local bar; in that video, officers wrestle Clark to the ground whilst Devins' mutilated corpse is visible in the background.

No, you didn't misread this. The cops and the government, of all people, allegedly distributed child pornography and snuff film featuring Devins to the media.

When Devins' mother learned of this, she was extremely distraught. So in July 2021, roughly two years after the murder, she sued Oneida County on behalf of Bianca's estate in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of New York. Devins' estate was represented by Carrie Goldberg, a feminist lawyer in New York City. If you didn't know, Goldberg is the same ambulance chaser who once wrote a letter to the U.S. Department of Justice asking for the prosecution of our forum's founders, Serge and Master.

You can read the 22-page complaint here:

Spoiler: Estate of Bianca Devins v. Oneida County (Complaint Dkt No. 1)

View: https://imgur.com/a/vWJduUZ

The Decision

View attachment 667711

The Oneida County DA's Office, under the leadership of District Attorney Scott McNamara (pictured here), argued that even if the allegations were true, the claims should be dismissed for a variety of reasons. And on September 29th, 2022, U.S. District Judge Glenn T. Suddaby sided with the County on dismissal. You can read the order here:

Spoiler: Estate of Bianca Devins v. Oneida County (Order Dkt No. 44)

View: https://imgur.com/a/Lzb8avH

View attachment 667716
Judge Glenn T. Suddaby

The 45-page order contains numerous points of law which will bore you so I won't elaborate too much, but the most significant one is Judge Suddaby's treatment of the federal child pornography claims under 18 U.S.C. §§2252A and 2255.

Here, the Court reasoned that although the material within the sex and murder tape constituted child pornography, Bianca Devins' estate lacked standing because she suffered no reputational harm—as a result of being dead at the time the child pornography was allegedly distributed. Therefore, Judge Suddaby granted the Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(1) and (6) motion to dismiss.

Or in other words, he BTFO'd the dead roastie's lawsuit.

View attachment 667719
Excerpt of Order, p. 37

Needless to say, child pornography is not great. But I do have to applaud Judge Suddaby for having the courage and conviction to apply the letter of the law, no matter what the personal feelings of Devins' simps may be on the issue. Absolutely BASED decision!

View attachment 667681

Spoiler: Tagging potentially interested individuals

@Master @MiSKiRaT @CurryLMAO @Noseman @Ricordanza @Izayacel @Ehwhatever @wastedTime @Pancakecel @zionpill @kretschmer @NorthernWind @My Name Jeff @RuudVanNistelrooy @Rice Rice Baby

 

[M3llow3lectrician]

>So six weeks after they met, Clark planned to murder Devins and commit suicide afterwards.

lol 6 weeks that escalated quickly,

imagine killing yourself or going to jail over some foid jfl.

I could see myself going to prison if I had a wife that cheated on me, but not for some BPD e whore I only knew for a month and a half. She must’ve had a horrible personality