I think that would be a instance where I could believe in his existence.
But I prefer to think we the divergent have souls that operates in higher frequencies, frequencies this world is not prepared to receive.
Something quite weird happened in the hospital this morning: I was coughing blood for the third morning in a row, so visited the hospital. In my country health care is free, so you can find every kind of people there. So, there appeared a crazy guy, wearing a mask, freaking out and doing weird movements, a chaotic autist in the middle of a sensorial outburst. He was alone, but he suddenly mentioned my name, saying I was already waiting for the medication (which was in fact true, I was sitting right there near him), but without looking at me. My eyes widened, one of the guards mentioned a media artist with the same name, thinking the crazy patient was refering to him, but I suspected he had some innate psychism and was able to tell my name out of nowhere, probably some undeveloped telepathy. The guy was uncontrollable in his crysis, and security had to remove him from the room. I looked into his eyes and noted he was desperate.
So my theory is that we have access to frequencies in our souls that the material world is not prepared to receive, and our physical bodies can even fail due to it. Science(tm) is not prepared for this kind of assumption as well, and will call this pseudoscience(tm).