Discussion Star Wars vs Lord of the rings | battle of goyslop

[Stupid Clown]

Which goyslop do you prefer? I grew up with both and prefer LOTR because the characters are more likable and there's less cringe than Star Wars. Gollum is also a pretty relatable character as a subhuman
View: https://youtu.be/UYpRSs7pzJo?si=yq74XzcIs8kNkw_p

 

[RegularManlet]

Idk if star wars is that good, I think its just a famous case of Just Be First Theory, similar to Penguinz0 blowing up on YT

 

[Stupid Clown]

Idk if star wars is that good, I think its just a famous case of Just Be First Theory, similar to Penguinz0 blowing up on YT

I'd argue that for original Star Wars. Prequels imo have the best sword fights and action of any fantasy or science fiction movie although they're a bit shitty outside of those fights. I'd much rather watch Revenge of the Sith than dune purely because of action and music.

 

[Fat Link]

Star Wars is more fun but Lord of the Rings is of vastly higher quality.

Star Wars was basically George just coming up with shit partially on the fly with no clear direction and I think I heard that he heavily ripped off from the Dune story or whatever for SW’s narrative.

Meanwhile LOTR’s was a fully fleshed out and carefully crafted story and universe created by a brilliant author.

So as far as overall quality and direction goes LOTR’s wins by a mile but again Star Wars is arguably more fun.

 

[Stupid Clown]

Star Wars is more fun but Lord of the Rings is of vastly higher quality.

Star Wars was basically George just coming up with shit partially on the fly with no clear direction and I think I heard that he heavily ripped off from the Dune story or whatever for SW’s narrative.

Meanwhile LOTR’s was a fully fleshed out and carefully crafted story and universe created by a brilliant author.

So as far as overs quality and direction goes LOTR’s wins by a mile but again Star Wars is arguably more fun.

Dune ripped off something else which Star Wars copied as well. I forgot what it was called. I agree. LOTR is much more quality and Tolkien is amazing. Personally I loved reading Tolkien. Especially Children of Hurin.

 

[Regenerator]

I never seen Lord Of The Rings & I haven't watched Star Wars for years now.

 

[Stupid Clown]

I never seen Lord Of The Rings & I haven't seen Star Wars for years now.

Surprised you never saw it.

 

[Regenerator]

Surprised you never saw it.

I never seen any Harry Potter or any MCU movie either.

 

[Stupid Clown]

I never seen any Harry Potter or any MCU movie either.

Harry Potter and marvel are the most subhuman goyslop. I watched some and fell asleep.

 

[Regenerator]

Harry Potter and marvel are the most subhuman goyslop. I watched some and fell asleep.

I rather watch paint dry than watch either of them.

 

[Stupid Clown]

I rather watch paint dry than watch either of them.

Based.

 

[RegularManlet]

I'd argue that for original Star Wars. Prequels imo have the best sword fights and action of any fantasy or science fiction movie although they're a bit shitty outside of those fights. I'd much rather watch Revenge of the Sith than dune purely because of action and music.

Yeah it was at least good for the action, everyone just shits on the prequels to follow the masses but I would sooner fall asleep watching the original boring trilogy than the prequels

 

[Stupid Clown]

Yeah it was at least good for the action, everyone just shits on the prequels to follow the masses but I would sooner fall asleep watching the original boring trilogy than the prequels

Agreed. OT is fucking boring