similarities between goatis and max stirner

[Remacy]

has anyone else noticed that goatis has a similar philosophy stirners or is that just me both often talk about spooks but goatis just refers to it as fake like for example countries, money, education and goatis believes to live in nature so therefor also anarchist

 

[yamnaya khhv]

Yea, their philosophies are pretty similar, except that stirner advocates for a non-hierarchichal way of living, with the union of egoists, and i think that goatis sees the world in a more tribalistic kind of way, where each tribe has its own hierarchy.

 

[Remacy]

Yea, their philosophies are pretty similar, except that stirner advocates for a non-hierarchichal way of living, with the union of egoists, and i think that goatis sees the world in a more tribalistic kind of way, where each tribe has its own hierarchy.

yeah i agree, happy to see someone sees the resemblance too

 

[Rapemaxxer]

Not really. Stirner is an egoist while Goatis is a naturalist. Goatis throws most spooks out the window, and replaces them with his own spooks ("nature") whereas Stirner is more consistent in his adamant rejection of spooks in general.

Goatis can appear similar to people like Stirner and Nietzsche on surface but beneath all the apparent similarities, he is quite different in what he actually preaches. He rejects things like modern medicine, mainstream diets and social norms because he finds them out of sync with what humans are "naturally" meant to be. This in itself is a spook, a metaphysical crutch. Stirner isn't concerned with the "natural state" of man. He rightly sees that as just another binding metaphysical narrative which turns the individual into a slave of abstract constructs.

 

[yamnaya khhv]

Not really. Stirner is an egoist while Goatis is a naturalist. Goatis throws most spooks out the window, and replaces them with his own spooks ("nature") whereas Stirner is more consistent in his adamant rejection of spooks in general.

Goatis can appear similar to people like Stirner and Nietzsche on surface but beneath all the apparent similarities, he is quite different in what he actually preaches. He rejects things like modern medicine, mainstream diets and social norms because he finds them out of sync with what humans are "naturally" meant to be. This in itself is a spook, a metaphysical crutch. Stirner isn't concerned with the "natural state" of man. He rightly sees that as just another binding metaphysical narrative which turns the individual into a slave of abstract constructs.

Well, they are both similar in that they both reject the metaphysical, apart from that they arent really similar in more ways, you could say goatis is egoist in some way seeing that he also promotes looking for your best interest and the one of those around, it is also true that i havent really studied that much of stirners philosophy.
Correct me if im wrong.

 

[Rapemaxxer]

Well, they are both similar in that they both reject the metaphysical

Goatis doesn't, even if he would like to pretend he does.