Well, BlackOps2Cel other than his eye area was solidly dimorphic. His eye area is just horrible. There is a lot more in that photo changed than just his eye area: hair, facial hair, lip coloring, etc and probably more that I'm missing. Not even close to just changing his eye area lol.
I think it breaks down like this:
Eye area in pictures.
Lower-third in real-life.
I routinely see guys with very good jawlines and from the side they could be mistaken as Chads just on that although otherwise they are probably normie tier in photos from the front. I think that's the reason as to why the threshold for success in real-life seems to be lower than online.