Horror games don't scare me either. FNAF only makes me "jump" because most of the games volume is at 20 decibels but the second you get jumpscared it's at 120 decibels.
That's what sucks so much about growing up.
I know we have some "grow up / be an adult"'cels here but video games are one of my copes and I used to really like horror games, especially survival horror. i've played Evil Dead, Silent Hill and Dino Crisis. Tbh, Dino Crisis felt extremely easy at the time.
I remember how I've finished the second one without dying once.
It was so strange.
From my childhood, I'd say that Silent Hill was the scariest for me.
Back then I didn't understand at all what the game was about.
I just loved it because of how disturbing it was.
Afaik, the last "horror" game that I've touched was Cry of fear. Never finished it. I just got bored.
Nowadays I just enjoy building stuff, which is why I even go back yo games like Harvest Moon on the N64 / PS.
Never touched Terraria or Stardew Valley though. Stardew Valley is apparently pozzed.
Then there is obviousely Minecraft and some may have a literal Minecraft fatigue, but I enjoy it. Maybe it's because I have started playing it late last year. Never touched it before.
It's fun and relaxing. I like the many biomes. My favourite is the wintter tundra biome.
I just love snow. It is the only natural cope that I have. Sadly it has barely snowed the last couple of years, in Germany ... .
I should probably go on holiday somewhere in the snowy mountains.
In fact, I should moneymaxx and get me a nice house in a snowy area and ho on vacation there, every now and then.
For now my virtual house in the winter biome will do.