Why wasn't Alaska chosen as the jewish state instead?

[Regenerator]

I mean... Alaska is more more isolated & has far more land mass than Palestine. It would have made far more logical sense to have Alaska be the jewish state than Palestine. Plus Alaska is only surrounded by Russia & America while having a jewish state be right next to muslim countries is a recipe for disaster.

Alaska's land area is approximately 1,723,337 square kilometers (665,384 square miles). Israel's land area is about 20,770 square kilometers (8,019 square miles).


To compare, Alaska is roughly 83 times larger than Israel in terms of land mass. If you were to overlay Israel onto Alaska, it would cover less than 1.2% of Alaska's total area.

 

[PersonalityChad]

Because the jews wanted Palestine specifically, since the ancient jew state was located in the same area lol

 

[Regenerator]

Because the jews wanted Palestine specifically, since the ancient jew state was located in the same area lol

Dumb as fuck reason.

 

[Glassness]

Holy land bla

 

[LeFrenchCel]

Should be put in Antarctica, they would have had a big ass island just for themselves

 

[misfit]

Jews are a desert people. They have lived in the sunny and arid Middle East for thousands of years. Why would they randomly choose to live in cold and frosty Alaska? Plus, they have a religious/ancestral link to that region, so it's more than just a piece of land to them.

 

[Trident]

Jews are a desert people. They have lived in the sunny and arid Middle East for thousands of years. Why would they randomly choose to live in cold and frosty Alaska? Plus, they have a religious/ancestral link to that region, so it's more than just a piece of land to them.

 

[Hoor Al-Ayn]

it's pretty straightforward
Palestine was chosen so they could leverage jewish history and the bible for the Zionist project
this thought process originated from theodor herzl himself, if i'm not wrong

telling people who've lived in Europe for a long time to go create a new state in some shitty place across the world isn't the easiest sell; they had to coat it in some religious/historical paint. even with Palestine, the zionists could only put their scheme in effect after the destruction and death of WW2/holocaust.

 

[Anarcho Nihilist]

I mean... Alaska is more more isolated & has far more land mass than Palestine. It would have made far more logical sense to have Alaska be the jewish state than Palestine. Plus Alaska is only surrounded by Russia & America while having a jewish state be right next to muslim countries is a recipe for disaster.

It's cold there. The Jews could build a Jewish state in a Jewish autonomous region, considering that their neighbors would be Russia and China, and they wouldn't have to fight anyone.

Jewish Autonomous Oblast - Wikipedia

en.m.wikipedia.org

 

[Anarcho Nihilist]

I mean... Alaska is more more isolated & has far more land mass than Palestine. It would have made far more logical sense to have Alaska be the jewish state than Palestine. Plus Alaska is only surrounded by Russia & America while having a jewish state be right next to muslim countries is a recipe for disaster.

The Jews had millions of options where to create their own state. But they are drawn to the Middle East, because of the climate and religious obsession. Many people for some reason think that Zionism is just Jewish nationalism without a religious background. Israel is literally a theocratic state, where on Saturdays, taxis and shops do not work. And the court of rabbis has enormous power.

 

[4life]

There shouldn’t be a Jewish state at all

 

[Regenerator]

It's cold there. The Jews could build a Jewish state in a Jewish autonomous region, considering that their neighbors would be Russia and China, and they wouldn't have to fight anyone.

Jewish Autonomous Oblast - Wikipedia

en.m.wikipedia.org

It's cold in Russia yet millions of people live there. What's funny is the autonomous region has far more land mass than Israel yet jews are so narcissistic they choose Palestine over both of them.

 

[plastic chewer]

There are no Arabs to exterminate in Alaska

 

[Zaraj11]

Should've been Madagascar

 

[Bazooka]

Because Reptile's require warm weather .

 

[Extern]

It should have been india because that would have been funny

 

[Defetivecuckachu]

Because Alaska wasn't their native land for a thousand years until the Romans conquered them and sacked their city?

 

[outerdarkness]

It was thought about.

This is a very good fictional alternative history about it.

The Yiddish Policemen's Union - Wikipedia

en.m.wikipedia.org

 

[Emba]

It was thought about.

This is a very good fictional alternative history about it.

The Yiddish Policemen's Union - Wikipedia

en.m.wikipedia.org

Brutal slaterly

 

[zd60]

Send them to tuvalu

 

[blackpillednigga]

There shouldn’t be a Jewish state at all

agreed. they already have new york and the entire western world

 

[DarkStar]

Should be put in Antarctica, they would have had a big ass island just for themselves

Perfect climate to kill the reptilians off also

Only trve Aryans can withstand the cold

 

[RandomGuy]

You Won't Expect This Stop on the Way to Gabala.


View: https://youtube.com/shorts/8zVUgQRdlcc?si=XNM_KqNzIjJcpNtd

 

[TooSomething]

Because the jews wanted Palestine specifically, since the ancient jew state was located in the same area lol

Was it though? Also, who gives a fuck? It's just religeous bullshit anyway.

Like, this is the only instance I can think of where a people have been given a territory because of "muh promised land".

 

[TooSomething]

Jews are a desert people. They have lived in the sunny and arid Middle East for thousands of years. Why would they randomly choose to live in cold and frosty Alaska? Plus, they have a religious/ancestral link to that region, so it's more than just a piece of land to them.

Nigga, you seriousely have the most fucked up reddit takes.

Why are you even here?

 

[TooSomething]

It should have been india because that would have been funny

THIS!!!

 

[Ferdi]

mandatory Palestine was chosen because it had the most opportunity for expansion, is an ancestral link to the Jews, and is far less isolated, their neighbors are not as intelligent so they can easily have more leverage in regional affairs as well, it was simply the most intelligent choice if you look at it from the point of view of the Jews