hypergamy, genetics, looks, etc all clump together to form the blackpill. It's a series of theories all backed by overwhelming scientific evidence. Sure it's cringe when you see journalists go "the HARMFUL INCEL IDEOLOGY" but soy aside it is an ideology. It's a set of beliefs.
OK, good. We're making progress.
hypergamy, genetics, looks, etc all clump together to form the blackpill.
They form aspects of the black pill. The black pill is about a lot more than looks, hypergamy etc.
It's a series of theories all backed by overwhelming scientific evidence.
Almost correct. It's a set of conclusions derived from that overwhelming scientific evidence. Some people take those conclusions and form theories of their own. Some are sensible (LMS), while others are total nonsense (ODT, or "Oofy Doofy Theory").
Sure it's cringe when you see journalists go "the HARMFUL INCEL IDEOLOGY" but soy aside it is an ideology. It's a set of beliefs.
False. To reiterate, it's a set of conclusions derived from scientific evidence. But it became more. The black pill evolved into a philosophy (note: this is very different than ideology) in its own right. It's a way of seeing and processing the world.
Philosophy explores truth, and the black pill (as a philosophy) explores truth in the harshest, coldest manner, void of all the social, political, tribal, and cultural baggage. The truths that the black pill commonly explores happens to be exactly those baggage-heavy domains. This is precisely why a lot of black pill truths are not PC and appear to be racist/misogynist/whateverist.
As a consequence of the black pill as a philosophy, elements of other philosophies get incorporated into it and it becomes muddied (or corrupted, if you're a purist). There's a very strong tendency towards nihilism ("it's over," "it never began," "cope or rope"), for example, and often times the black pill is misunderstood as some kind of subset of nihilism. While it's true that the black pill lets you pierce the veil on many things and allows you see things for how they are, the outlook of the individual looking at everything through the black pill could run the risk of falling into nihilism or similar pessimistic worldviews.
These individual outlooks, however, are not representative of the whole. Incels and their personal beliefs, worldviews, and morals are not unified into a monolithic system aka ideology. Just spend time here and you'll see how vastly different one user is from the other in terms of these things. For the black pill to be an ideology, it has to be a set of beliefs prescribed to a group which also define it. The black pill is neither prescriptive, nor does it identify or define incels. There are blue pilled, red pilled, and black pilled incels. You'll find the former two all over the place, including here, unfortunately. There are also blue pilled, red pilled, and black pilled non-incels.
You've already alluded to it, but the reason why I'm extremely hostile to such phrasings of "incel ideology" and "black pill ideology" is, not only that it's logically and factually incorrect, but because it's what media types (academics too) use to push a narrative that demonizes and vilifies us to a broader audience. Using their language in here - either wittingly or unwittingly - is extremely tilting.