Does being blackpilled mean that we should disagree with women at every turn, or that everytime somebody says something anti-women we should turn off our brains and cheer them o? That's not rational in the slightest, which is the complete opposite of what the blackpill is supposed to represent, which is accepting truths even if they're uncomfortable. This lack of logic and extreme desire of disagreeing simply because the person you're argung with is "the other" is literally what the people who call themselves our enemies do with us. That's precisely what we should avoid if we are better than them.
I already explained my reasonings in that thread, but I'll briefly touch on them again.
OP's logic is that if somebody doesn't care about you they should receive the death penalty. Thankfully, the vast majority of people do't actually think like this. If they did, society would be much more hostile and violent which would in turn breed more hate and would caue more pain in the world, making more outcasts with extremist beliefs, like for example wanting to kill people simply because they don't like them.