Welcome to Incels.is - Involuntary Celibate Forum

Welcome! This is a forum for involuntary celibates: people who lack a significant other. Are you lonely and wish you had someone in your life? You're not alone! Join our forum and talk to people just like you.

NSFW have you guys heard of "redo of healer"?.

I don't like anime.
 
It's just a fantasy bro , we need some real action . Will one of us one day get revenge of all those who had bullied.him.
 
Just finished till the current chapter, it's quite interesting.
 
basically, it's about a guy who is bulled and abused by women
and men

basically to make sure he always performs healing duties they get him addicted to a drug and imprison him and a series of people (men and women) rape him in hopes they'll get powers by raping him *shrug*

when he gets free he revenge-rapes the women and revenge-murders the men

pppppproblem?
 
basically, it's about a guy who is bulled and abused by women, and he gets his revenge by manipulating, gaslighting, and raping the women who abused him.

here's a link if you want to read it. https://mangakakalots.com/manga-id-chapter/kaifuku_jutsushi_no_yarinaoshi/chapter_1
That's porn
It's just a fantasy bro , we need some real action . Will one of us one day get revenge of all those who had bullied.him.
Just finished till the current chapter, it's quite interesting.
and men

basically to make sure he always performs healing duties they get him addicted to a drug and imprison him and a series of people (men and women) rape him in hopes they'll get powers by raping him *shrug*

when he gets free he revenge-rapes the women and revenge-murders the men

pppppproblem?
That's rape
lol ngl I used to unironically think this anime was a 6/10 show at the least but after watching Scamboli's review on it I change my mind. Although it's extremely based and has God tier coomfuel, Redo of Healer is a fucking stupid show and unironically rating it a 6 would be an insult to actual 6/10 anime


View: https://youtu.be/0HJ9NNtkFNw
 
I click on the thread and see it’s from over 2 years ago. Brutal time pill
 
lol ngl I used to unironically think this anime was a 6/10 show at the least
but after watching Scamboli's review on it I change my mind.
This shit is 15 minutes long can you give me cliff notes as to what in particular he said to change your mind?

This faggot is using mechanical voice and not accompanying this w/ a text transcript of the text he fed into the machine showing he doesn't want us to be able to critically read/copy the text and just sit through his dozen-plus minutes

Why is this worth my time?

Although it's extremely based and has God tier coomfuel, Redo of Healer is a fucking stupid show and unironically rating it a 6 would be an insult to actual 6/10 anime
I don't know how one objectively rates shows on decile scale anyway

people adding big numbers is like pretending you're doing technical grading on criteria like a school teacher

whereas mostly people do this on feels so they may as well just say 'thumbs up' or 'thumbs down'

but I guess I should ask, how WOULD you rate it on the decile scale?
 
This shit is 15 minutes long can you give me cliff notes as to what in particular he said to change your mind?

This faggot is using mechanical voice and not accompanying this w/ a text transcript of the text he fed into the machine showing he doesn't want us to be able to critically read/copy the text and just sit through his dozen-plus minutes

Why is this worth my time?
Nigga just watch it. It has 1.6 million views and almost 100k likes. Plus Scamboli is one of the only actual entertaining and funni anime YouTubers. That should be enough to convince you :feelsseriously:
 
Nigga just watch it. It has 1.6 million views and almost 100k likes.
IDGAF
Plus Scamboli is one of the only actual entertaining and funni anime YouTubers. That should be enough to convince you :feelsseriously:
you've been here more than a year and I have vague memories of positive interactions with you (shitty as my memory is) so I guess that's enough to go on your word

I'd still prefer for you to mention particular talking points as to what was important to you

for example if I point out something that's BS in this vid and you say "that's not the part that convinced me" it's frustrating

it's easier if I know what to attack here

HATE THIS GUYS VOICE ITS SO ECHOEY it's suffering to listen to this even if I turn down my bass
 
Weebs getting serious :feelshaha:
 
I don't know how one objectively rates shows on decile scale anyway

people adding big numbers is like pretending you're doing technical grading on criteria like a school teacher

whereas mostly people do this on feels so they may as well just say 'thumbs up' or 'thumbs down'

but I guess I should ask, how WOULD you rate it on the decile scale?
My rating system follows a Normal Distribution:

View: http://i.imgur.com/55fOxx8.gif

with Mean = 5, X = 1,2,...,10, Standard Deviation = 1.8. My scores correspond to a percentile, with 5 being average = 50th percentile (technically should be 5.5, but w/e). To determine exact scores, I use a weighted average : (.33characters)+(.27story)+(.15art)+(.15sound)+(.05value)+(.05enjoyment).
10 (99.7%) - Masterpiece. Among the very best of all time. Strong in every category, with deep, powerful themes, and singular artistic vision.
9 (98.7%) - Elite. Superb characters and story with very strong themes. It may have a couple minor flaws, but is otherwise head and shoulders above almost everything else.
8 (95%) - Excellent. High quality in most aspects. Dynamic characters and interesting premise. May have a few hiccups or lack that special flair for a truly extraordinary experience.
7 (87%) - Very good. Solid structure with memorable characters and/or story. May be missing one or two key pieces. May have some inconsistency in quality.
6 (71%) - Good. Above average material that leaves at least a passing impression on the viewer. Usually lacking in one major area.
5 (50%) - Satisfactory. It does an adequate job exploring the premise, but is otherwise unremarkable. This score is also reserved for anime that were strong in one category but very weak in another.
4 (29%) - Mediocre. Has a few redeeming qualities--often high production values at the expense of writing or solid story structure. May have played it too safe or too ambitious.
3 (13%) - Inadequate. Far below average. Likely sub-par in most categories, may have 1-2 redeeming qualities.
2 (5%) - Bad. Painful to watch. Has at most 1 redeeming quality. Can make fun of it at the expense of your sanity.
1 (1%) - Failure. Mind-bleach. Terrible in most aspects and fails to deliver in any meaningful or entertaining way.
Brutal :fuk:
 
Last edited:
you've been here more than a year and I have vague memories of positive interactions with you (shitty as my memory is) so I guess that's enough to go on your word
Oh wow, feels good to be remembered ngl :feelscomfy:
I'd still prefer for you to mention particular talking points as to what was important to you

for example if I point out something that's BS in this vid and you say "that's not the part that convinced me" it's frustrating

it's easier if I know what to attack here
I don't know how one objectively rates shows on decile scale anyway

people adding big numbers is like pretending you're doing technical grading on criteria like a school teacher

whereas mostly people do this on feels so they may as well just say 'thumbs up' or 'thumbs down'

but I guess I should ask, how WOULD you rate it on the decile scale?
Honestly I have shit memory as well so I can barely remember tbh. I had to rewatch that video to jog my memory. Keyaru's cum (out of all of the other bodily fluids) can give people power ups jfl, Keyaru changes his name to Keyarga and makes his face slightly different than it was before he went rogue andmagically no one can tell it's him, they tell us healers are useless and seen as the jester of their party yet they have OP abilities like being able to absorb the knowledge and skills of the person you're healing, physically change your (and others people's) face and appearance at will, oneshot enemies, etc

I would rate it a 4/10 tbh but don't get me wrong, I enjoyed watching it a fuck ton. However, personal enjoyment isn't a factor when it comes to rating for me tbh I try to rate anime as objectively as I can. There's just way too much hilariously dumb shit in this anime for me to give it any higher than a 4 :feelsjuice:
HATE THIS GUYS VOICE ITS SO ECHOEY it's suffering to listen to this even if I turn down my bass
Massive cope, he has chad voice :chad:
Weebs getting serious :feelshaha:
Joined: Dec 20, 2021
Posts: 8
Online: 6h 27m

Now comes the part where we throw our heads back and laugh
 
just give me cliffs as to your reasoning (if you remember what you watched so well)

and also change your username so I can @W you without needing to consult a character map for your pseudo-vowel
 
just give me cliffs as to your reasoning (if you remember what you watched so well)
I just did in the post above maby
and also change your username so I can @W you without needing to consult a character map for your pseudo-vowel
Just copy and paste the "Ø" theory :feelsthink:

Wait you can change your username now? :feelsahh::feelsahh::feelsahh:
 
Keyaru's cum (out of all of the other bodily fluids) can give people power ups jfl
he's able to do shit like piss vaccines to poisons he takes so I don't know why this surprises you, he's DBz-level biochem

Keyaru changes his name to Keyarga and makes his face slightly different than it was before he went rogue andmagically no one can tell it's him
it's hiding in plain sight like Clark Kent basically

there's a lot of resemblances between people so all you really need is a slight change

peoplw would think "if it was really as disguise it would be a big difference" (just as you've exhibited) so if it was only a slight difference, people think "naw couldn't be, it's just my subconscious jumping to conclusions based on the similarity"

they tell us healers are useless and seen as the jester of their party yet they have OP abilities like being able to absorb the knowledge and skills of the person you're healing, physically change your (and others people's) face and appearance at will, oneshot enemies, etc
you're confusing the average "healer" of that realm (who is indeed a jester) with Keyaru who is a legend-tier "Healer"
IE day one he can regrow a limb while normal career healers can't : that should be your first hint he's an exception

I would rate it a 4/10 tbh but don't get me wrong, I enjoyed watching it a fuck ton. However, personal enjoyment isn't a factor when it comes to rating for me tbh I try to rate anime as objectively as I can.
based on what criteria?

There's just way too much hilariously dumb shit in this anime for me to give it any higher than a 4 :feelsjuice:
have countered all your points above, try harder

Massive cope, he has chad voice :chad:
that's his internal monologue voice which he doesn't actually outwardly manifest until he levels up enough to re-arrange his vocal chords when he assumes the form of a chad body

you can hear the contrast when his "inner self" speaks to his "reborn self" here:


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3vtgslg43k&t=21


his IRL voice from birth is very weak/effeminate, he doesn't even recognize the harsh hateful telepathy-voice of his previous life's self

maybe you forgot this since it's been a while since you watched

I just did in the post above maby
ehhh
Just copy and paste the "Ø" theory :feelsthink:
takes too long, I want your vowel to be a single stroke away

Wait you can change your username now? :feelsahh::feelsahh::feelsahh:
mods should make exception for you or just autoreplace all pseudovowels absent on keyboards
 
he's able to do shit like piss vaccines to poisons he takes so I don't know why this surprises you, he's DBz-level biochem
Sounds like plot armor to me idk
it's hiding in plain sight like Clark Kent basically

there's a lot of resemblances between people so all you really need is a slight change

peoplw would think "if it was really as disguise it would be a big difference" (just as you've exhibited) so if it was only a slight difference, people think "naw couldn't be, it's just my subconscious jumping to conclusions based on the similarity"
:lul::lul::lul::lul::lul:

I doubt the author was thinking about it that deeply considering how dumb this show is jfl
you're confusing the average "healer" of that realm (who is indeed a jester) with Keyaru who is a legend-tier "Healer"
IE day one he can regrow a limb while normal career healers can't : that should be your first hint he's an exception
Oh lol I forgot that was even a thing. You memorymog me
based on what criteria?
I don't have any problem with cruelty and extreme degeneration in fiction. In fact, I'm the kind of person who actively skin others to make armchairs and hats and cook their meat into a good stews in games. For people who doesn't know Rimworld, isn't that pretty disgusting and quite frankly inhuman? I will keep doing it though.

But even someone like me can't stand Redo of Healer. It's just so fucking terrible.

The MC's ability is plot-weapon. Under the pretense of Healing, the author twisted it into all forms of unbelievable, unrelated thing like Heal: Mindwipe, Heal: Inplant Memory....etc by establishing a thin, unrealistic connection between these and Heal.This is basically bullshit, just like power of friendship. The only thing we need to know is that he was given the plot-weapon that allows him to brainswash, transfer memories, hypnotize,... and more, other R-18 weapons.

But I was also fine with bullshits. I have low expectations for isekai series and basically just come to read them for some low-effort self-satisfaction, ones that you don't need to use your brain much to feel. However, despite being an isekai work with the theme around extreme revenge without restraint, Redo of Healer was very unsatisfying even for a fellow degenerate. And this is because:

The MC and the plot are cowards. His revenge is weak, petty and pitiful.

I don't care that he broke her fingers, made her beg for it, then did it all over again, THEN broke her legs and raped her. No, it's the fact that he brainwashed his mortal enemy, the princess into an innocent childlike state with no memory and gaslight her into further sexual depravity that I find pathetic. Emphasis on Brainwashing. Because it's not even her anymore and she was no longer there to experience the humiliation of being tortured by someone she's always trampled on. He was basically doing the pitiful, petty act of raping an innocent person.

He then changed his identity and appearance, continuing to be sadistic and extremely cruel to other revenge targets. That's good and all, except that it was no longer [Him] who's doing the revenge. He was not sending out any messenge and no one in the world knows what was coming for them. He basically did this to satisfy his urges for sadistic violence and sexual torture. That is pitiful and weak.

On another occasion, he drugged the strongest swordswoman with aphrosidiac and tricked her into thinking that he was a good person and also had sex with her. Basically, he sugarcoated and tricked a powerful enemy into cooperating rather than doing something more satisfying like, I don't know.... Conquering her normally? He had already won. Why couldn't he conquered the weakened girl normally and had to opted to trickery? That is pathetic.

And more.

Just like how right at the start, MC opted to disguise himself as another person, his revenge methods are never straightforward and would always include boring things like brainwashing, hypnotizing, and trickery. There was never a situation where he could proudly proclaim that: "It was I, [former lowly slave], who has done all this [unspeakable act of tortures] to this [important person]." and not immediately shy away and erase history afterward.

In my Rimworld games, if some soldiers from the Imperial Empire come and kill my dog, I will make sure to skin them, harvest the organs, and send the whole package back to them. They will know that it was me, and it was their subject whose parts that was in the package, and had the game allowed for it I would also let them know that it was because they killed 1 dog. It is only proper etiquette. What is NOT proper etiquette and is boring and petty is kidnapping innocent passerby for no reason.

In Redo of Healer, they're ditching good story structure, good abilities that make sense, good characters, and good writings, in exchange for self-service and low-effort satisfaction. Then why are they so unthorough with the good parts?If you're brainwashing people, disguising yourself as someone else, or tricking people, you're no longer taking revenge on the same person, It's no longer you who takes revenge, or you're not really taking revenge at all. There is nothing satisfying, vindicating, or even revenge-like about any of those situations, and it baffles me that the author, the fans, and the whole Japanese culture that agree to make this an anime cannot comprehend this.

It should be about sending a messenge. And yet MC is hiding pitifully behind faked identifies, fabricated memories, and lies, even though he's not only got plot armor, but also plot weapon.

Someone from another thread already said this: "The fact that someone not only wrote this story, but also that there are also a vocal group of pitiful basement dwelling losers that will actively defend this garbage is so disturbing to me. It's shameless, vile torture porn with nothing to say, meant to appeal to the demographic of deadbeats who resent all women because they've never had a girlfriend. I genuinely wish I could erase this show from my memory. "

And as a pitiful basement dwelling loser who've never had a girlfriend, even I wish I could erase this piece of crap from my memory. I almost achieved that, but then this garbage just HAS to become popular.
have countered all your points above, try harder
Why are you seething :lul:
that's his internal monologue voice which he doesn't actually outwardly manifest until he levels up enough to re-arrange his vocal chords when he assumes the form of a chad body

you can hear the contrast when his "inner self" speaks to his "reborn self" here:


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3vtgslg43k&t=21

his IRL voice from birth is very weak/effeminate, he doesn't even recognize the harsh hateful telepathy-voice of his previous life's self

maybe you forgot this since it's been a while since you watched

I meant Scamboli :feelskek::feelskek::feelskek:
Idk why it's so hard for you to accept the fact that Redo of Healer objectively isn't good
takes too long, I want your vowel to be a single stroke away
:fuk:
mods should make exception for you or just autoreplace all pseudovowels absent on keyboards
lol I doubt they would even if I asked
 
Last edited:
anyone who actually considers this a good show is just blinded by the coom

Setsuna though:ahegao:
 
I doubt the author was thinking about it that deeply jfl
sure he was, he has long-term plans, you can see them unfold gradually if you're not distracted by the base reactions to the extreme events

I'm the kind of person who actively skin others to make armchairs and hats and cook their meat into a good stews in games.
I'm skeptical you found a game intricate enough to do that, I don't even think Dwarf Fortress is that complex.


For people who doesn't know Rimworld, isn't that pretty disgusting and quite frankly inhuman? I will keep doing it though.
IMO putting the parts of the dead to use is useful pragmatism compared to just letting them decompose. If you have moral qualms it should be about who you kill and why.

IE in Overlord it doesn't bother me that the protagonist lets his minions do that with human body parts: it's the fact that he lets them kill them when they so clearly outclass the humans they probably could've been turned into vassals like he did with the sexslave-turned-maid his butler rescued.

But even someone like me can't stand Redo of Healer. It's just so fucking terrible.
pointless statement since we're about the "why", I don't care about overviews and generalizations

The MC's ability is plot-weapon. Under the pretense of Healing, the author twisted it into all forms of unbelievable, unrelated thing like Heal: Mindwipe, Heal: Inplant Memory....etc by establishing a thin, unrealistic connection between these and Heal.
It's not thin or unrealistic IMO, they go into explanations as to why.
It's definitely a lot more specific than Slime Isekai or Shield Hero tbh
or stuff like Naruto where "I can focus my chakra and do anything" is pretty much the rule
what exactly are you comparing this to in levels of realism, Golgo 13?

This is basically bullshit, just like power of friendship. The only thing we need to know is that he was given the plot-weapon that allows him to brainswash, transfer memories, hypnotize,... and more, other R-18 weapons.
it has limits, we see those limits, he sees them too

despite being an isekai work with the theme around extreme revenge without restraint, Redo of Healer was very unsatisfying even for a fellow degenerate. And this is because:

The MC and the plot are cowards. His revenge is weak, petty and pitiful.

I don't care that he broke her fingers, made her beg for it, then did it all over again, THEN broke her legs and raped her. No, it's the fact that he brainwashed his mortal enemy, the princess into an innocent childlike state with no memory and gaslight her into further sexual depravity that I find pathetic.
What should he do at that point instead? Just keep breaking fingers and raping her ad nauseum?

I think he just got bored and outgrew it and wanted to try something more creative and civilized once he got the base barbarism out of his system.

Emphasis on Brainwashing. Because it's not even her anymore and she was no longer there to experience the humiliation of being tortured by someone she's always trampled on. He was basically doing the pitiful, petty act of raping an innocent person.
We don't know all the details on this. For example: maybe subconsciously Flare IS aware and alert of everything that is happening to this conscious mind.

After what was done to her, seeing this faux-consciousness made of fragments of her old self enthusiastically consenting could be a new kind of humiliation for Flare.

As for the "rape", although the sex was based on some deception ("you're my beloved girlfriend, we've been fucking for years" or something along those lines) she chooses to take this at face value and not question it.

It's also questionable as to whether this is really a distinct person, an artifice, a fragment...

He then changed his identity and appearance, continuing to be sadistic and extremely cruel to other revenge targets. That's good and all, except that it was no longer [Him] who's doing the revenge.
Yes he is. It just isn't always known, and when it is, he might do a delayed-reveal.

He was not sending out any messenge and no one in the world knows what was coming for them.
That's a pretty smart thing to do until you've understood the mechanics of your enemy and are guaranteed a win.

If he had revealed his power level right off the bat he would've been assassinated SO fucking quick.

He didn't have a legendary weapon, remember? He had to steal that off one of the other "destined" heroes and it was only via that he was able to trounce the captain-of-the-guard (hawk-eye or whatev he was called)

He basically did this to satisfy his urges for sadistic violence and sexual torture. That is pitiful and weak.
if all he wanted was to torture and engage in violence he could've done that to anyone
the speciifcity of his targets shows he has some sense of justice and morality (however twisted) guiding his actions

he didn't do shit like "I'm going to go and rape the wife and daughterof the soldier who raped me" for example

On another occasion, he drugged the strongest swordswoman with aphrosidiac and tricked her into thinking that he was a good person and also had sex with her.
'good' is subjective, I think he perceives himself as sorta-good
he also realizes she is intensely loyal and prob wouldn't turn to his side knowing what he did to princess, and he needed a backup sword to unravel the empire

what we need to realize is this guy knows first-hand what it is to fall in love with Flare and how shocking it is to be utterly betrayed, to know her true self
he knows how he would've resisted that thought of her, and how swordswoman would've resisted it

about the only way he could win her over is use enough deception to get her in bed, teacher her body the truth as a tender lover, and then maybe he'll reveal the truth in 5 years or so when teh empire has fallen

Basically, he sugarcoated and tricked a powerful enemy into cooperating rather than doing something more satisfying like, I don't know.... Conquering her normally?
the thing about Kureha Clyret the Sword Saint is, in all fairness, she is biased by a huge web of bias and lies that Keyaru needs to deal with

ie "you can perform my sword techs, you must have stolen them, maybe tortured my famiyl to learn the technique" or something along those lines (in truth he learned it by healing her arm)
ie naturally assuming his demi-human loli companion is a slave even thogh he asked her consent to come along

she's the one who overstepped first, by just attacking him w/o giving him a chance to explain, trying to kil lhim and shit
so a little deception like "I rescued the princess" doesn't seem that far out of line

it's like "oh, I liked to you? well you tried to kill me" so it sort of balances out

the intent here is I think to reveal the truth of the Jioral kingdom to Kureha, and the mass-worship of the princess amongst the common populace (including Kureha) is so massive that pretty much 99% of the population won't believe Jioral is immoral without Flare coming on board to insult it and get wheels turning and questioning

basically you need the Flare deception (rebellious princess rescued) just to get the idea into people's heads, which is (aside from her firepower) one of the reasons I think that Keyaru decided to bring her along (besides the daily pseudo-rapes)

He had already won. Why couldn't he conquered the weakened girl normally and had to opted to trickery? That is pathetic.
He hadn't won. The kingdom was still standing at that point. He needed Kureha out of the way (not trying to kill him) without murdering/maiming her, and ideally as an ally out helping to dismantle the empire.


right at the start, MC opted to disguise himself as another person, his revenge methods are never straightforward and would always include boring things like brainwashing, hypnotizing, and trickery.
That's tactics/strategy

He's NOT omnipotent, if he used a purely frontal assault the mages/rogues working for the monarchy would've killed him.

There's a massive numbers-game going on, and he hasn't had the opportunity to skill-copy the best-of-the-best

That's why he needed allies, and he did make compromises manipulating them to varying degrees to acquire them.

There was never a situation where he could proudly proclaim that: "It was I, [former lowly slave], who has done all this [unspeakable act of tortures] to this [important person]." and not immediately shy away and erase history afterward.
so what would he do next after this?
run off and let Flare chase him? kill Flare?

Keyaru is mature enough I think to realize Flare is more of a symptom than a cause and there is a darker illness at heart of the kingdom that gives birth to bitches like that.
I think he realized while conquering Flare (and he DID reveal who he was, as he raped her) that it wasn't satisfaction, it didn't really change the root of the problem.

It's at this point he surpassed the short-sighted goal of revenge against Flare and instead sought revenge against the society which birthed her, so instead of fixating on "I'm gonna make Flare feel bad" he co-opts her (rewrites her) as a tool in that greater endeavour.

Basically he leveled-up after getting XP for defeating the mid-boss and recruited her to his party to challenge the final bosses.


In my Rimworld games, if some soldiers from the Imperial Empire come and kill my dog, I will make sure to skin them, harvest the organs, and send the whole package back to them. They will know that it was me, and it was their subject whose parts that was in the package, and had the game allowed for it I would also let them know that it was because they killed 1 dog. It is only proper etiquette.
LOL they wouldn't give a shit because it's just a disposable soldier
and they might avoid killing YOUR dog but will go and kill a bunch of other people's dogs
so you haven' really solved the problem of their misbehavior, which requires dismantling their entire society
that's what Keyaru is doing


What is NOT proper etiquette and is boring and petty is kidnapping innocent passerby for no reason.

Kureha was NOT an innocent passerby.

Lemme remind, in case you don't recall much of episod 5, of what Kureha decided to do to cause Keyaru to decided to disable her via an aphrodesiac smoke bomb (which I'll remind you she countered via a leg-stab)



he was walking peacefully down the street, his back exposed to a pair of girls clearly very happy to be with him
yet the foid ambushes him and tries to assassinate him

Keyaru has done far worse to people with a much greater justification for attacking him:
I'll remind you again, the two soldiers guarding the princesse's bedroom in ep 1, he DECAPITATED them, and they weren't ambushing an innocent man, they were defending what they thought was an innocent girl against a violent invader. There's no indication they knew any of the shit she was up to w/ her prisoners.

Keyaru shows his growth as a char by not immediately murdering Kureha for doing that: I think partly because he got to know her back when he regrew her arm, but also because he knew she was probably misled by propaganda.

She likely would not accept the truth of the empire's degneracy coming from a guy combatting it with his own lesser form of degeneracy, so he had to polish the truth into a pseudo-truth that she could process due to her simplific black-and-white views of good and evil.

It's her own burden to do her own research into the truth: she is accountable for what BS she believes.
In that respect: her own negligence in being aware of the villains she served led her to defend the empire of Flare in all it's degeneracy, and contributed to keeping Keyaru as a slave all those years, even after he had healed her an she had promised to protect him.

Keyaru is basically helping Kureha fulfill her promise, by goading her into believing what she needs to believe so that she would be willing to actually honor it.

Look how easily she was willing to murder him based on pure propaganda. Her life is forfeit and at her mercy and he is mercifl: doesn't kill her, doesn't rewrite her like flare, just doesn't come clean about rewriting Flare (her life and free will are forfeit due to her crimes, so it's his perogative)

she's basically proven to be too dense to perceive on her own the empire's degeneracy so Keyaru is trying to guide her to the truth through sexual healing :) once she trusts him via some orgasms and turns against the empire, THAT is the important thing, not whether she'll feel betrayed and hate him later once the empire has fallen

Keyaru is basically wrecking his chances at true love (Kureha was a pretty good canddiate for that) to make overthrowing the empire more of a sure thing, since true love and things working out with Kureha was never a guarantee.

In Redo of Healer, they're ditching good story structure, good abilities that make sense, good characters, and good writings, in exchange for self-service and low-effort satisfaction.
You're generalizing again, which is pointless.
We need to be talking specific names and specific events here or it's just foid-deflection.

Then why are they so unthorough with the good parts?If you're brainwashing people, disguising yourself as someone else, or tricking people, you're no longer taking revenge on the same person, It's no longer you who takes revenge, or you're not really taking revenge at all.
He DOES reveal himself eventually.
Does he at first wait a couple minutes before revealing "I'm Healer not your Captain of Guard" when confronting Princess Flare in ep 2? Yes. So what?

As for why he disguised the captain as himself, that was to throw them off his trail while he built connections for his long-term plans.

Basically denying himself immediate gratification because it'd get him killed and he needed to outmaneuver them: it's smart.

You also have to perceive this isn't revenge isolated in a petty way at a single person, but at the soil in which she grew.

He's not just ripping out the flower (Flare) he's salting the fucking earth (Jioral Kingdom monarchy) so wretches like her won't flourish there.

this is a much grander vision and ultimately much better for the world

There is nothing satisfying, vindicating, or even revenge-like about any of those situations, and it baffles me that the author, the fans, and the whole Japanese culture that agree to make this an anime cannot comprehend this.
Sure there is.
What you're not grasping here is that he got satisfaction in ep 1.
He's not a mental-child like Flare where he gets ongoing satisfaction from torturing the same person for years on end.
He tortured/raped her for at most maybe a couple hours and it didn't fill the void in him.

Basically he's superior to Flare because unlike her, he actually realized this shit wasn't enough to truly satisfy him and fill the void in him, so he cast his eyes higher.

He doesn't look at Flare as a person/rival anymore. She was defeated far too easily for that. She just becomes a vehicle to use against the enemy he perceives beyond her once he conquers hero: Jioral.

It'd be kind of like the difference between trying to get revenge on a specific terrorist bomber vs the religion that motivated/financed him.

It should be about sending a messenge. And yet MC is hiding pitifully behind faked identifies, fabricated memories, and lies, even though he's not only got plot armor, but also plot weapon.
You can't send a message without dismantling the media structure.
you need to realize how powerful the monarchy is in shaping the narrative here
Yeah you can scare the monarchy but unless you can defeat them, they'll fuck you up

Until you can actually defeat the monarchy, it's not the smartest idea to "send a message" about what a badass you are.
That's why Keyaru masqueraded as Keyaruga and disguised Renard to look like Keyaru so they thought they caught "Flare's murderer"

This way their guard is down and he has room to maneuver and do shit like build his harem/guardians, earn money, gain information about the Demon Lord, etc.

You seem to be under the assumption he's so omnipotent that strategy and tactics don't matter, but they DO.

You also see Ains Ool Gown in Overlord equally cautious and pragmatic, and the same thing in Slime Isekai.

They're super-tier power levels who can trounce 99% of the population too, but they know hypothetically there are threats out there they can't handle, and so they're cautious and conservative at first, testing the waters of their environment and how much of it they can master.

I swear it's like you expect Keyaru to drag Flare into the King's chamber and rape Flare in front of him. You really think it'd be THAT easy?

Someone from another thread already said this: "The fact that someone not only wrote this story, but also that there are also a vocal group of pitiful basement dwelling losers that will actively defend this garbage is so disturbing to me. It's shameless, vile torture porn with nothing to say, meant to appeal to the demographic of deadbeats who resent all women because they've never had a girlfriend. I genuinely wish I could erase this show from my memory. "

And as a pitiful basement dwelling loser who've never had a girlfriend, even I wish I could erase this piece of crap from my memory. I almost achieved that, but then this garbage just HAS to become popular.
Not sure why you're engaging in generalization foid-speak. I don't care about pointless nonspecific insults like "the entire ting is crap" or whatev.

I do however enjoy our more useful preceding conversation about specific events and characters, so hopefully we can stick to that.

I meant Scamboli :feelskek::feelskek::feelskek:
ah okay... well I dunno I think Keyaru's "mature voice" is more manly than Scamboli's


Idk why it's so hard for you to accept the fact that Redo of Healer objectively isn't good
there is no way for anyone to be completely objective , we all subjective interpretations
there is no 'fact' here

but I am willing to hear your condemnations and give counter-arguments, as I have above
anyone who actually considers this a good show is just blinded by the coom
come at me with PARTICULARS or GTFO pleb
 
Last edited:
sure he was, he has long-term plans, you can see them unfold gradually if you're not distracted by the base reactions to the extreme events


I'm skeptical you found a game intricate enough to do that, I don't even think Dwarf Fortress is that complex.



IMO putting the parts of the dead to use is useful pragmatism compared to just letting them decompose. If you have moral qualms it should be about who you kill and why.

IE in Overlord it doesn't bother me that the protagonist lets his minions do that with human body parts: it's the fact that he lets them kill them when they so clearly outclass the humans they probably could've been turned into vassals like he did with the sexslave-turned-maid his butler rescued.


pointless statement since we're about the "why", I don't care about overviews and generalizations


It's not thin or unrealistic IMO, they go into explanations as to why.
It's definitely a lot more specific than Slime Isekai or Shield Hero tbh
or stuff like Naruto where "I can focus my chakra and do anything" is pretty much the rule
what exactly are you comparing this to in levels of realism, Golgo 13?


it has limits, we see those limits, he sees them too


What should he do at that point instead? Just keep breaking fingers and raping her ad nauseum?

I think he just got bored and outgrew it and wanted to try something more creative and civilized once he got the base barbarism out of his system.


We don't know all the details on this. For example: maybe subconsciously Flare IS aware and alert of everything that is happening to this conscious mind.

After what was done to her, seeing this faux-consciousness made of fragments of her old self enthusiastically consenting could be a new kind of humiliation for Flare.

As for the "rape", although the sex was based on some deception ("you're my beloved girlfriend, we've been fucking for years" or something along those lines) she chooses to take this at face value and not question it.

It's also questionable as to whether this is really a distinct person, an artifice, a fragment...


Yes he is. It just isn't always known, and when it is, he might do a delayed-reveal.


That's a pretty smart thing to do until you've understood the mechanics of your enemy and are guaranteed a win.

If he had revealed his power level right off the bat he would've been assassinated SO fucking quick.

He didn't have a legendary weapon, remember? He had to steal that off one of the other "destined" heroes and it was only via that he was able to trounce the captain-of-the-guard (hawk-eye or whatev he was called)


if all he wanted was to torture and engage in violence he could've done that to anyone
the speciifcity of his targets shows he has some sense of justice and morality (however twisted) guiding his actions

he didn't do shit like "I'm going to go and rape the wife and daughterof the soldier who raped me" for example


'good' is subjective, I think he perceives himself as sorta-good
he also realizes she is intensely loyal and prob wouldn't turn to his side knowing what he did to princess, and he needed a backup sword to unravel the empire

what we need to realize is this guy knows first-hand what it is to fall in love with Flare and how shocking it is to be utterly betrayed, to know her true self
he knows how he would've resisted that thought of her, and how swordswoman would've resisted it

about the only way he could win her over is use enough deception to get her in bed, teacher her body the truth as a tender lover, and then maybe he'll reveal the truth in 5 years or so when teh empire has fallen


the thing about Kureha Clyret the Sword Saint is, in all fairness, she is biased by a huge web of bias and lies that Keyaru needs to deal with

ie "you can perform my sword techs, you must have stolen them, maybe tortured my famiyl to learn the technique" or something along those lines (in truth he learned it by healing her arm)
ie naturally assuming his demi-human loli companion is a slave even thogh he asked her consent to come along

she's the one who overstepped first, by just attacking him w/o giving him a chance to explain, trying to kil lhim and shit
so a little deception like "I rescued the princess" doesn't seem that far out of line

it's like "oh, I liked to you? well you tried to kill me" so it sort of balances out

the intent here is I think to reveal the truth of the Jioral kingdom to Kureha, and the mass-worship of the princess amongst the common populace (including Kureha) is so massive that pretty much 99% of the population won't believe Jioral is immoral without Flare coming on board to insult it and get wheels turning and questioning

basically you need the Flare deception (rebellious princess rescued) just to get the idea into people's heads, which is (aside from her firepower) one of the reasons I think that Keyaru decided to bring her along (besides the daily pseudo-rapes)


He hadn't won. The kingdom was still standing at that point. He needed Kureha out of the way (not trying to kill him) without murdering/maiming her, and ideally as an ally out helping to dismantle the empire.



That's tactics/strategy

He's NOT omnipotent, if he used a purely frontal assault the mages/rogues working for the monarchy would've killed him.

There's a massive numbers-game going on, and he hasn't had the opportunity to skill-copy the best-of-the-best

That's why he needed allies, and he did make compromises manipulating them to varying degrees to acquire them.


so what would he do next after this?
run off and let Flare chase him? kill Flare?

Keyaru is mature enough I think to realize Flare is more of a symptom than a cause and there is a darker illness at heart of the kingdom that gives birth to bitches like that.
I think he realized while conquering Flare (and he DID reveal who he was, as he raped her) that it wasn't satisfaction, it didn't really change the root of the problem.

It's at this point he surpassed the short-sighted goal of revenge against Flare and instead sought revenge against the society which birthed her, so instead of fixating on "I'm gonna make Flare feel bad" he co-opts her (rewrites her) as a tool in that greater endeavour.

Basically he leveled-up after getting XP for defeating the mid-boss and recruited her to his party to challenge the final bosses.



LOL they wouldn't give a shit because it's just a disposable soldier
and they might avoid killing YOUR dog but will go and kill a bunch of other people's dogs
so you haven' really solved the problem of their misbehavior, which requires dismantling their entire society
that's what Keyaru is doing




Kureha was NOT an innocent passerby.

Lemme remind, in case you don't recall much of episod 5, of what Kureha decided to do to cause Keyaru to decided to disable her via an aphrodesiac smoke bomb (which I'll remind you she countered via a leg-stab)

View attachment 552854

he was walking peacefully down the street, his back exposed to a pair of girls clearly very happy to be with him
yet the foid ambushes him and tries to assassinate him

Keyaru has done far worse to people with a much greater justification for attacking him:
I'll remind you again, the two soldiers guarding the princesse's bedroom in ep 1, he DECAPITATED them, and they weren't ambushing an innocent man, they were defending what they thought was an innocent girl against a violent invader. There's no indication they knew any of the shit she was up to w/ her prisoners.

Keyaru shows his growth as a char by not immediately murdering Kureha for doing that: I think partly because he got to know her back when he regrew her arm, but also because he knew she was probably misled by propaganda.

She likely would not accept the truth of the empire's degneracy coming from a guy combatting it with his own lesser form of degeneracy, so he had to polish the truth into a pseudo-truth that she could process due to her simplific black-and-white views of good and evil.

It's her own burden to do her own research into the truth: she is accountable for what BS she believes.
In that respect: her own negligence in being aware of the villains she served led her to defend the empire of Flare in all it's degeneracy, and contributed to keeping Keyaru as a slave all those years, even after he had healed her an she had promised to protect him.

Keyaru is basically helping Kureha fulfill her promise, by goading her into believing what she needs to believe so that she would be willing to actually honor it.

Look how easily she was willing to murder him based on pure propaganda. Her life is forfeit and at her mercy and he is mercifl: doesn't kill her, doesn't rewrite her like flare, just doesn't come clean about rewriting Flare (her life and free will are forfeit due to her crimes, so it's his perogative)

she's basically proven to be too dense to perceive on her own the empire's degeneracy so Keyaru is trying to guide her to the truth through sexual healing :) once she trusts him via some orgasms and turns against the empire, THAT is the important thing, not whether she'll feel betrayed and hate him later once the empire has fallen

Keyaru is basically wrecking his chances at true love (Kureha was a pretty good canddiate for that) to make overthrowing the empire more of a sure thing, since true love and things working out with Kureha was never a guarantee.


You're generalizing again, which is pointless.
We need to be talking specific names and specific events here or it's just foid-deflection.


He DOES reveal himself eventually.
Does he at first wait a couple minutes before revealing "I'm Healer not your Captain of Guard" when confronting Princess Flare in ep 2? Yes. So what?

As for why he disguised the captain as himself, that was to throw them off his trail while he built connections for his long-term plans.

Basically denying himself immediate gratification because it'd get him killed and he needed to outmaneuver them: it's smart.

You also have to perceive this isn't revenge isolated in a petty way at a single person, but at the soil in which she grew.

He's not just ripping out the flower (Flare) he's salting the fucking earth (Jioral Kingdom monarchy) so wretches like her won't flourish there.

this is a much grander vision and ultimately much better for the world


Sure there is.
What you're not grasping here is that he got satisfaction in ep 1.
He's not a mental-child like Flare where he gets ongoing satisfaction from torturing the same person for years on end.
He tortured/raped her for at most maybe a couple hours and it didn't fill the void in him.

Basically he's superior to Flare because unlike her, he actually realized this shit wasn't enough to truly satisfy him and fill the void in him, so he cast his eyes higher.

He doesn't look at Flare as a person/rival anymore. She was defeated far too easily for that. She just becomes a vehicle to use against the enemy he perceives beyond her once he conquers hero: Jioral.

It'd be kind of like the difference between trying to get revenge on a specific terrorist bomber vs the religion that motivated/financed him.


You can't send a message without dismantling the media structure.
you need to realize how powerful the monarchy is in shaping the narrative here
Yeah you can scare the monarchy but unless you can defeat them, they'll fuck you up

Until you can actually defeat the monarchy, it's not the smartest idea to "send a message" about what a badass you are.
That's why Keyaru masqueraded as Keyaruga and disguised Renard to look like Keyaru so they thought they caught "Flare's murderer"

This way their guard is down and he has room to maneuver and do shit like build his harem/guardians, earn money, gain information about the Demon Lord, etc.

You seem to be under the assumption he's so omnipotent that strategy and tactics don't matter, but they DO.

You also see Ains Ool Gown in Overlord equally cautious and pragmatic, and the same thing in Slime Isekai.

They're super-tier power levels who can trounce 99% of the population too, but they know hypothetically there are threats out there they can't handle, and so they're cautious and conservative at first, testing the waters of their environment and how much of it they can master.

I swear it's like you expect Keyaru to drag Flare into the King's chamber and rape Flare in front of him. You really think it'd be THAT easy?


Not sure why you're engaging in generalization foid-speak. I don't care about pointless nonspecific insults like "the entire ting is crap" or whatev.

I do however enjoy our more useful preceding conversation about specific events and characters, so hopefully we can stick to that.


ah okay... well I dunno I think Keyaru's "mature voice" is more manly than Scamboli's



there is no way for anyone to be completely objective , we all subjective interpretations
there is no 'fact' here

but I am willing to hear your condemnations and give counter-arguments, as I have above

come at me with PARTICULARS or GTFO pleb
Redo of a Healer has to be by far the worse fantasy manga I've ever had the displeasure of reading and laying my eyes upon in my entire life as a human being and that says a lot considering the shit I've read .

I'll through points as to why I hate this story with a burning passion .

  1. The title itself is a lie : The MC is called the 'Healing Hero' yet he can do all kinds of non-healing shit like changing somebody's appearance or one-shot killing them somehow . I get that in revenge stories the power difference is meant to be on the avengers side , but I feel like the author was misleading people into believing that the MC is the underdog of the story , when its far from it .
2 . Story and Plot : Its absolutely bland to a fault , while I admit that like me some good ol'fashioned revenge stories every now and again . This story completely ruins it with shoddy characters and lazy writing .

3. The Rape : Okay , to be honest this part doesn't really bother me too much as it does other people . But the sex and rape in this story is used to death for the sake of shock value and quite frankly it got so bad to the point where I thought I was reading a goddamn hentai of all things .

The sex in this story also feels very forced , where if you supposedly have sex with one of the heroes you can level up ? That has be without a doubt one of the stupidest things I have ever heard before in my entire life .

And I would also like to point out that since the MC quite commonly uses rape to take revenge on those who wronged , it makes him just as bad if not worse than the antagonist , but I will get to that later .

4. The Characters are complete and utter shit : The harem only exists for the sake of sex and to act as the MC's personal cheerleading squad/sex slaves . Which the MC has been assembling since the very start , which makes him no better than the Sword Hero .

And the antagonist of this story get this the worst , where they are so poorly written and only exist for the sake of making the MC look good by comparison .

The Sword Hero ? She's a serial sadistic rapist now . The Cannon Hero ? A pedophile who has his own network of little sex slave boys .

You know , when you need a torpedo rapist to make your MC look like the good guy , than he probably isn't that good a person to begin with .

It seems like every goddamn character in this story solely exists for the benefit of the MC . The antagonist are bad just for the sake of being bad and making the MC look good by comparison , the harem is just there for fanservice and sex .

Speaking of the MC ...

5. The MC himself is a piece of sentient human garbage whose horrendous actions are only justified by massively unrealistic Freduian Excuse which was caused by the author bending the world over backward to screw him over , to make his horrid actions look justified .

Instead of proposing an actually interesting moral conflict where the MC's horrid actions make him become just as bad as the people he is taking revenge on , the story just makes everybody else a million times worse to justify his horrid actions !

And of course , anybody who doesn't suck him off ( Literally and metaphorically ) is evil with no redeemable qualities or devoid of any kind of real personality or even backstory . Yes , I am rolling my eyes here .

In conclusion , the MC is by far the worse character in the entire series and has been without a doubt the worse isekai MC I've ever had the displeasure of reading . I am genuinely amazed that this manga got a goddamn anime . Standards for making an anime must have really fallen if they're willing to animate this piece of shit .

Now excuse me , I must now go bleach my eyes to hopefully forget I ever saw this piece of shit to begin with .
 
That Dude was very based , He resets time Back 4 years and trys everything to get His Wants Met

Maybe the Anime was a little Bland but that Dude was the shit
 
extremely dogshit anime that has nothing to offer but fan service
I've seen hentai with a better plot/storyline

Just finished till the current chapter, it's quite interesting.
found the cuck
 
truly ahead of his time, what a visionary

lol ngl I used to unironically think this anime was a 6/10 show at the least but after watching Scamboli's review on it I change my mind. Although it's extremely based and has God tier coomfuel, Redo of Healer is a fucking stupid show and unironically rating it a 6 would be an insult to actual 6/10 anime


View: https://youtu.be/0HJ9NNtkFNw

i love that nigga scamboli. been watching him for over a year now and he has absolutely never missed
 
someone bump this tomorrow so I can respond to wolf my pills are hitting right now and I can't focus enough
 
i love that nigga scamboli. been watching him for over a year now and he has absolutely never missed
Same :feelscomfy:

1640477104519

someone bump this tomorrow so I can respond to wolf my pills are hitting right now and I can't focus enough
bumo
 
should I even read the response above to me or does it have spoilers for the post-anime events of ROH from manga
 

Users who are viewing this thread

shape1
shape2
shape3
shape4
shape5
shape6
Back
Top