PhineasSpear
Misagapic Nihilist
-
- Joined
- Feb 11, 2026
- Posts
- 1,317
- Online time
- 1d 20h
View: https://www.reddit.com/r/relationship_advice/comments/1sqscyf/my_23m_girlfriend_23f_told_me_things_that_id/
Later on he makes an update thread around four days later:Added nsfw tag because i have to go in detail.
So for context, before my girlfriend and i got together we were friends for a while. Now during this time she’d keep bringing up this one guy from her past to whom she was supposed to lose her virginity to but didn’t. The only thing i had known till now is that this was a casual hookup but nothing had happened since she couldn’t “put it in”.
I genuinely didn’t mind because i have also had sexual encounters before. Fast forward a few months and now we’re dating. And for some reason during one of our calls (currently LDR) the topic shifts to him and she talks about that night again. But for some reason she tells me something she never mentioned before and something id rather never have heard.
She mentioned how towards the end of the night he had “finished on her tits”. Completely unprompted. Since hearing this i have not been able to see her the same anymore. I understand that everybody has their own past but i genuinely wish i never heard this.
Also something that bothers me is how she said she hated that guy and was very uncomfortable but then goes on to let him do that to her?
I dont know how to feel and i would really love to hear some advice.
View: https://www.reddit.com/r/relationship_advice/comments/1su6pwc/my23m_girlfriend_23f_told_me_things_id_rather_not/
This is an update to my previous post on this same subreddit.
Thanks to everybody who commented. I had a conversation with my girlfriend about the things that bothered me and I’m left even more troubled. So i thought id post an update here.
Before i begin, i wanted to clear up a confusion that a lot of people had. Im not upset that she had partners before me. Im not upset that the guy “finished on her tits”. This is not retroactive jealousy. One thing i hate in a relationship is when i feel like I’m being lied to. With this whole incident i hate that she tells me one thing but then gives me reason to believe otherwise. As somebody with clear boundaries she would never let anybody do anything to her that she didn’t like.
My only issue with this whole thing is that she said she hated the experience and him. But has given me reason to believe that maybe thats not true. I’ll explain further as i describe the conversation i had with her.
When i brought this up i gave her multiple points which left me confused.
- The fact that she only ever spoke about him unprompted multiple times when we were friends and a few more times when we got together.
- How she had called him “out of her league” and that he was the hottest guy in college. Once even told me how hot his current girlfriend is. All things that speak highly of him, which i personally wouldn’t do if i hated someone.
- During this conversation for some reason she read out her journal entry from that day. She had told me before (completely unprompted) that they had done nothing the entire night. In the journal she had written that she hated the night and that she “never came once”
- How she hung out with him after this night with a common friend group and still followed him on Instagram (to this day). Im only adding this here because some of the comments told me she could have been traumatised. Which i dont think is the case because of this.
Her only answers to all this was that when she said out of her league she meant that he has way more experience than her, which genuinely doesn’t make sense to me. And when asked about the journal entry she said that she wrote never finished but she meant that she didn’t have a good time. I told her that doesn’t make sense and that if they did actually do something she can tell me but she refused.
The entire reason the “finishing on her tits” thing is bothering me is because it adds on to the list of contradictions. If she liked him, she liked him. End of story. If she had sex with him or at least did some finger stuff, fine. It really doesn’t bother me.
What i hate is how i was continuously told she hated him and that nothing happened but she keeps giving me reasons to believe otherwise. The conversation with her did not help at all because she kept repeating the same things she had already told me.
How do i make her understand what’s bothering me? I really love her and i hate that she thinks I’m bothered by her past. I just want to feel like I’m not being lied to
Just Be First is undefeated. Also this dude's a massive idiot and a cuck for thinking her past doesn't matter.Edit: people from the comments of this post and the previous one seem to think this guy was an ex. He was not.
He was a mutual friend of hers with whom she decided to hook up with. But according to her she hated it and didn’t sleep with him again.
Here are some interesting comments I found from both threads.
View: https://www.reddit.com/r/relationship_advice/comments/1sqscyf/comment/oh9xmj7/
The comment above is OP's reply to one of the comments
View: https://www.reddit.com/r/relationship_advice/comments/1su6pwc/comment/ohz9oq6/
View: https://www.reddit.com/r/relationship_advice/comments/1sqscyf/comment/ohdtk75/





