I'm still pretty much the same now. While I did like the scene girls, I was never that picky. Light, dark, scene, emo, valley, punk, goth, geeky, nerdy, whichever.
If anything, I was more into Asian girls back then than I am now, but I really didn't care as long as I saw they lived close enough for me to meet when I tried online and simply if I was attracted to them, which were most of them.
It wasn't like now as I don't remember seeing many girls being fat at all. The neon weird colors and half shaven heads weren't a thing either.
Remembered this one girl that worked in the mall that I think was at least 5 years older than me. Tanned, long wavy hair and looked like a punk girl. I also remember being such a bluepilled idiot that thought I had a chance with her. Would've always gone to the store because I did like what they sold and whenever I was ready to pay I would aim for her to do the transactions.
Then, of course, I saw she was flirting with a guy that came to the store, no clue if it was a random guy or someone she was dating. That day I stopped going there. Place closed a few years later and I didn't care.