In my experience, there are three types of people: those who want to believe it, those who don't want to believe it, and those who are neutral.
These categories apply to supernatural events, urban legends, creepypastas, or any other bizarre cases that lack logical explanation.
I'm more of a neutral person. In regards to aliens, I really don't care. My main focus is on things happening on this planet rather than intergalactic civilizations built by aliens. I guess it takes faith to believe in such things.