This has to be a troll thread, being 6'6 and muscular with a robust corporeal frame and muscles and an average face absolutely decimates being a manlet with a nice face. This isn't even a real thread.
Need proof just look at how many disgusting faced NBA / college players slay on the daily just because they are tall and lean. Money, but it's mainly being tall and lean and muscular too
It looks like LeBron James' face caught on fire and someone tried to put it out with an icepick, but his robust height, frame and muscles make him desireable.
Face > all matters most of the time except in extreme hypotheticals like this, in this case it's no contest.