To get good looking people you have to have both female and male choice balanced. Eg.. as Europe was before 1900 for many centuries.
I've seen places where females have been choosing for generations. All the people, including the women become these hugely tall, Ogre people with anvil Chins, massive arms, just 'big', but not aesthetic and not healthy.
The Dutch used to be strikingly attractive.. and there are Dutch from their former colonies who still have the Dutch look and normal aesthetic proportions of their bodies, legs & arms. But the modern Dutch I've seen, after generations of female choice are just these freakishly tall, weird looking people.