By far the most over rated one, but this is an incredibly based thread.
in my opinion everything you mentioned except hobbies matters, all of those are pretty much effects of confidence, if a guy is actually confident woman views him as strong and also he is capable of putting other men down with his jokes or shaming
Physical traits are more prioritized. It doesn't matter how funny a guy is, if he doesn't have the looks, it won't make anyone like him romantically. It might make a good looking guy more preferable to his peers on average but even that is not definite, some foids prefer the guy who gives dangerous vibes.
Tall good looking guy with decent frame = Confident
