Has anyone seen this isekai?

[Clavicus Vile]

I’ve been considering giving it a watch.

 

[weaselbomber]

i did its aight
nothing special

 

[Fantasea]

I read the manwha. I dropped when he revealed that he was King GrAY to his parents. died of cringe reading that chapter.

 

[Mecoja]

Isekai is a suicide psyop

 

[chalk son]

nah

 

[sadlemon]

It's mushoku tensei but worse. The manga is a literal copy 1 by 1 of the first chapters. What's more there's nothing interesting about it, in MT you at least have Rudy pervertness and if you watch the anime god tier animation, while TBATE is a powerpoint slide

 

[DutchCel01]

It's mushoku tensei but worse. The manga is a literal copy 1 by 1 of the first chapters. What's more there's nothing interesting about it, in MT you at least have Rudy pervertness and if you watch the anime god tier animation, while TBATE is a powerpoint slide

The novel of tbate clears mushuko tensei its legit not even in the same ballpark story wise.

 

[(っ◔◡◔)っ]

Isekai is a suicide psyop

 

[weaselbomber]

The novel of tbate clears mushuko tensei its legit not even in the same ballpark story wise.

larp, the Mushoku Tensei lightnovel is unironically one of the best.

 

[starystulejarz]

Troon Mc don't watch!!!

look at that tranny foid gait jews are doing it on purpose, not a single male walks like that we have balls and a dick

 

[sadlemon]

The novel of tbate clears mushuko tensei its legit not even in the same ballpark story wise.

I can't speak for the novel but people say that it has been adapted well to manga, and the manga as i've said before is a literal copy of mushoku tensei in it's start.

And i'm being generous to not call it a blatant rip off. Let's mention the things that they share in common: Transmigration, smart kid in his young years, prodigy in magic, uses an incredible magic spell being really young, father is a swordsman. It doesn't help that both protagonist and their respective fathers are really similar.

After that the novels differ but while MT has a lot of interesting things like MC dealing with past trauma, teaching an entitled brat, his learning of magic, etc.

TBATE was just isekai generic slop, there's nothing that i've said wooow about it. I just read a little bit still, just when he found the elf grandpa. You can't say "b-buuuut it gets better after that" because you need to hook someone at the start, and this series has a really, really weak start.

 

[DutchCel01]

larp, the Mushoku Tensei lightnovel is unironically one of the best.

One of the best hahahahahaha thats larp bro cmon now

 

[DutchCel01]

I can't speak for the novel but people say that it has been adapted well to manga, and the manga as i've said before is a literal copy of mushoku tensei in it's start.

And i'm being generous to not call it a blatant rip off. Let's mention the things that they share in common: Transmigration, smart kid in his young years, prodigy in magic, uses an incredible magic spell being really young, father is a swordsman. It doesn't help that both protagonist and their respective fathers are really similar.

After that the novels differ but while MT has a lot of interesting things like MC dealing with past trauma, teaching an entitled brat, his learning of magic, etc.

TBATE was just isekai generic slop, there's nothing that i've said wooow about it. I just read a little bit still, just when he found the elf grandpa. You can't say "b-buuuut it gets better after that" because you need to hook someone at the start, and this series has a really, really weak start.

Well it does get better after that thats the thing. The start is basic isekai. Till the elf grandpa is like what, 20 novel chapters? It has 520+ rn.

 

[DutchCel01]

I can't speak for the novel but people say that it has been adapted well to manga, and the manga as i've said before is a literal copy of mushoku tensei in it's start.

And i'm being generous to not call it a blatant rip off. Let's mention the things that they share in common: Transmigration, smart kid in his young years, prodigy in magic, uses an incredible magic spell being really young, father is a swordsman. It doesn't help that both protagonist and their respective fathers are really similar.

After that the novels differ but while MT has a lot of interesting things like MC dealing with past trauma, teaching an entitled brat, his learning of magic, etc.

TBATE was just isekai generic slop, there's nothing that i've said wooow about it. I just read a little bit still, just when he found the elf grandpa. You can't say "b-buuuut it gets better after that" because you need to hook someone at the start, and this series has a really, really weak start.

The mc in tbate will also deal with his past and the trauma and issues from it. You just didnt read it yet.

 

[weaselbomber]

One of the best hahahahahaha thats larp bro cmon now

That's correct. What I enjoy the most are the perspective shifts to other people - it happens in the first volume, you see Zenith's POV and her view of Rudeus. The believable character reactions to the very unusual MC is frankly the series' strongest point, in addition to the very vibrant world that is painted. A lot of isekai struggle with the scope of the world and everything feels limited to the MC and his cast, but Mushoku is the only I've seen atm where the world feels like it *actually* has shit that goes on and the MC isn't the Messiah which things only ever happens around.

 

[weaselbomber]

I'd still say Zaregoto and Spice and Wolf are better light novels though, mostly because of the really boring Fitz arc that went on for far too long. But the stuff that comes after like the Asura Kingdom arc are just as good as the displacement arc.

 

[fukurou]

it gets shittier by the episode.
a Chad Gary Stu gets reincarnated as a Chad Gary Stu with magic powers.

 

[sadlemon]

Well it does get better after that thats the thing. The start is basic isekai. Till the elf grandpa is like what, 20 novel chapters? It has 520+ rn.

It's subpar, if the start is not great i can't expect the novel to get better "eventually". Also not only did he copy better works like Mushoku tensei, but lacked individuality. If it's one of your first novels and you enjoyed it, i can understand that you consider it great. But saying that it's better than MT is just plain ignorance.

 

[AsakangaHalo]

I’ve been considering giving it a watch.

View attachment 1469303

looks like shit

 

[DutchCel01]

It's subpar, if the start is not great i can't expect the novel to get better "eventually". Also not only did he copy better works like Mushoku tensei, but lacked individuality. If it's one of your first novels and you enjoyed it, i can understand that you consider it great. But saying that it's better than MT is just plain ignorance.

I read mushuko tensei before i did tbate. I dont like the pervertness of rudeus, also didnt really like the way the story started shaping itself. I like orsted tho.

 

[DutchCel01]

That's correct. What I enjoy the most are the perspective shifts to other people - it happens in the first volume, you see Zenith's POV and her view of Rudeus. The believable character reactions to the very unusual MC is frankly the series' strongest point, in addition to the very vibrant world that is painted. A lot of isekai struggle with the scope of the world and everything feels limited to the MC and his cast, but Mushoku is the only I've seen atm where the world feels like it *actually* has shit that goes on and the MC isn't the Messiah which things only ever happens around.

see tbate has the perspective shift aswell. To an entire other continent which has different systems for magic and power.

 

[DutchCel01]

see tbate has the perspective shift aswell. To an entire other continent which has different systems for magic and power.

I like mushuko tensei aswell though dont get me wrong. There is just certain stuff i dislike about it too.