The red pilled views vs black pill is basically a form of correlation vs causation. So yes, considering the red pill doesn't actually understand the nature of things and comes to false conclusions they are absolutely not compatible. Red pillers might think they know what improved a man's looks and social standing, but they don't actually know why.
For example : A high tier normie has a good face and a strong chin and jaw but let himself go for months. Has terrible hair and a patchy stupid looking beard.
The red piller will give advice to get a haircut and shave and it works. The red piller believes and concludes that the haircut and the shave are the main factor of improving the guys looks. This leads to all the useless advice you see constantly thrown around in those circles (and at this point in the mainstream).
The black pilled male, who is far superior, understands that the genetic potential was there all along and the high tier normie always had a strong chin and jaw and the removal of the patchy beard was a minor component of the improvement.