Ericfffc
Captain
★★★★
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2021
- Posts
- 1,850
Proves nothing
Omnipotence just means the ability to do everything that is possible, which doesnt include that rock paradox.Concept of omnipotence debunked in one sentence :
Can God create a rock so heavy that He cannot lift it?
If God is omnipotent, why would His abilities be limited by a physical concept like a rock?Concept of omnipotence debunked in one sentence :
Can God create a rock so heavy that He cannot lift it?
He talked so much and yet he said absolutely nothing
alr I guess that if a concept "outside of logic" there is no point arguing it.Omnipotence just means the ability to do everything that is possible, which doesnt include that rock paradox.
But let's just say that it did include everything that is possible and isn't, now god can lift that rock!
"But it's logically impossible!! Explain how!!!" It doesnt need to make sense, it's outside of logic
Not a religiouscel but a common answer would be that its a test from godalr I guess that if a concept "outside of logic" there is no point arguing it.
As you are an incel you know that foids are "designed" (in evolution there is no design but let's assume god designed them) to truly love 20% of the male population. Why god created them that way when we know love is one of the most important thing in male life as it gives a purpose to continue enduring life. And if you believe in evolution, why do the principle of evolution is basicly injustice when the creator of this mechanism is supposed to be just ?
IC. But how can someone reach the conclusion that an omnipotent (make no logical sense) , good creator is behind the universe when the universe seems independant from these notion of good and evil. So why creating such a test when you give no clue to find your existence with rational reasoning jfl ?Not a religiouscel but a common answer would be that its a test from god
The question was if he could create something too heavy so he cannot lift it. It just basicly shows that god is at least limited by logic. If he can create this rock he is not omnipotent because he cannot lift it. If he cannot creates such a rock he is not omnipotent. It just shows that this concept of omnipotence makes no logical sense.If God is omnipotent, why would His abilities be limited by a physical concept like a rock?
If omnipotence includes the ability to transcend logic, then the question itself becomes meaningless, as it tries to confine an unlimited being to the constraints of human reasoning.The question was if he could create something too heavy so he cannot lift it. It just basicly shows that god is at least limited by logic. If he can create this rock he is not omnipotent because he cannot lift it. If he cannot creates such a rock he is not omnipotent. It just shows that this concept of omnipotence makes no logical sense.
and then how u reach the conclusion that this entity exists (ik u don't believe in it) if it "transcend human reasoning". I mean if it does not make any sense to the logic (gifted by god) then u could believe in anything, so your belief rely on the endoctrination of ur parents or someone else I guess. And btw in islam god itself ask us to use our reasoning ability to reach the conclusion that he exists in the quran if I remember well.If omnipotence includes the ability to transcend logic, then the question itself becomes meaningless, as it tries to confine an unlimited being to the constraints of human reasoning.